Fresh ingredients, delicious food, warm atmosphere. What more can you ask for? At II Tomato, we're here to serve you and yours with the most delicious Italian and American classics New Castle has to offer. We only use the freshest ingredients to craft our homemade dishes, ensuring your taste buds' delight.
From delectable antipasti items to beautifully crafted entrees, at II Tomato we make sure you and your stomach are well taken care off. Don't forget to check out our beer and wine menu as well. We have an extensive selection to choose from to enjoy in our restaurant, or to go. II Tomato welcomes you to experience everything we have to offer.
From delectable antipasti items to beautifully crafted entrees, at II Tomato we make sure you and your stomach are well taken care off. Don't forget to check out our beer and wine menu as well. We have an extensive selection to choose from to enjoy in our restaurant, or to go. II Tomato welcomes you to experience everything we have to offer.
Services
Nino's passion for food runs deep. That passion has only grown over the years and has been shared with many family and friends. II Tomato has been around since 1986 and started with just a humble storefront. Our mission has always been to craft homemade dishes, made with fresh ingredients. As a locally owned, family owned restaurant, we take pride in serving New Castle with the absolute in food and experience when they visit II Tomato.
Reviews (10)
Natalie Thompson
Jan 01, 2022
Report
Shannon Watts
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Emily Reed
Oct 31, 2021
Report
Two Tomatoes offers a great ambiance but do not care about their customers. We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here, we reserved the room over two months in advance and picked our meal with set prices prior to the event. Two days before the event, the owner calls us and says the price of meat has gone up and we have to pay the difference even though prices were already set. They also told us we could not change our mind about the menu because they already bought the meat for our buffet, regardless of the price change. Additionally, they would not cooperate with us, they seem nice and concerning
Joe Edge
Oct 24, 2021
Report
I loved this place and have been going there for years. Last night at the bar was the most angry and disgusted bartender I ever encountered. Not only angry but when my friend and I had our beers refreshed she refilled the SAME glasses and we had no idea if we got back our own glass. When we asked her about it she said don't worry I did not mix them up, REALLY!. Working for tips I don't think so, left without ordering and will not return until she is gone.
Rhonny Dam
Sep 27, 2021
Report
Keith Snyder
Sep 26, 2021
Report
Zeke Selma
Aug 12, 2021
Report
DO NOT COME HERE!
I worked here for a little while and their kitchen is disgusting. It always smelled like rotten food and bleach, you were able to smell both upon walking into the kitchen. I’m saying this to inform the public not to bash anyone. The owners are fake when it’s convenient and rude to your face if they don’t have things their way. What happened to the customer is always right?? The place may look nice but they don’t keep it up to par, very disappointed.
I worked here for a little while and their kitchen is disgusting. It always smelled like rotten food and bleach, you were able to smell both upon walking into the kitchen. I’m saying this to inform the public not to bash anyone. The owners are fake when it’s convenient and rude to your face if they don’t have things their way. What happened to the customer is always right?? The place may look nice but they don’t keep it up to par, very disappointed.
Susan Mulligan
May 29, 2021
Report
The atmosphere is great. The decor is lovely and elegant with some fun touches like the silver ink blot bowls on the walls! The wait staff and hostess are friendly, on point and give excellent service.
My food came out timely, looked and smelled tasty, and it was delicious! I had a great time with my Grandpa here. It is definitely a place to take family, friends or a date to.
They have a lot of choices on the menu and all seem fair priced to the great quality and quantity you receive.
My food came out timely, looked and smelled tasty, and it was delicious! I had a great time with my Grandpa here. It is definitely a place to take family, friends or a date to.
They have a lot of choices on the menu and all seem fair priced to the great quality and quantity you receive.
Marc Suber
Apr 25, 2021
Report
Yetemar-Kenyell Cross
Oct 05, 2020
Report
New Castle is distinctively blessed to have so many local eateries and friendly people all over the town. I came here for the first time, and saw a more fanciful, nicely done interior than expected. It’s where you can go for a nice night out, or simply a nice evening dinner. The Meatball Risotto appetizer was delicious. The pictures didn’t do my Chicken Vincenzo entree justice. The portion was so plentiful, I had another full meal to take home. I recommend this place and the support of local restaurants. Audrey was a great server. Their herbed olive oil is also great; I wanted to pour it over
