Pitman Kalkhoff Sicula & Dentice
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Pitman Kalkhoff Sicula & Dentice
Our injury lawyers have earned a statewide reputation by protecting the rights of the elderly and their families. When nursing home abuse or neglect harms your loved one, put our team of lawyers, paralegals, nurses and staff to work for you. With a proven record of success, at PKSD our personal injury lawyers provide legal solutions for your automotive accident damages claim and will fight for the justice you deserve.

The personal injury lawyers at PKSD have decades of experience helping injury victims throughout the state of Wisconsin, including those who have suffered from car crashes, motorcycle collisions, truck accidents, brain injury and wrongful death. Our law firm also has the largest nursing home neglect practice in Wisconsin.
Services
The injury lawyers of Pitman, Kalkhoff, Sicula & Dentice, S.C. are pleased to see you've taken the first step in protecting yourself and your family by seeking a lawyer. PKSD focuses solely on injury cases, choosing to devote our skills and resources to those injured and their families for whom we can make the greatest difference through our outstanding service, legal expertise, vast resources and passionate advocacy.
Attorney Jeffrey A. Pitman focuses on representing victims of serious personal injury and nursing home abuse and neglect. In more than 28 years of practice, Mr. Pitman has handled thousands of personal injury cases and obtained tens of millions of dollars in verdicts and settlements in Wisconsin, Illinois, Iowa and New Mexico.
Attorney Sicula received his undergraduate degree Cum Laude from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and his law degree Cum Laude from Marquette University. He is admitted to practice in the state of Wisconsin, the Eastern and Western Districts of the United States District Court of Wisconsin and the Seventh Circuit of the United States Court of Appeals.
Mr. Kalkhoff, a partner with Pitman, Kalkhoff, Sicula & Dentice since 2002, offers extensive experience as a trial attorney when representing victims of personal injury. Throughout his legal career, Mr. Kalkhoff has obtained many jury verdicts and favorable settlements for his clients throughout Wisconsin.
Attorney Patrick C. O'Neill has tried over 85 jury trials and has settled thousands more out of court. He has tried and settled cases worth tens of millions of dollars for his clients. Patrick is a Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate by the National Board of Trial Advocacy.

Patrick has achieved the "AV" peer review rating from Martindale-Hubbell which signifies the highest level of professional excellence for lawyers practicing more than ten years.Patrick is a member of the Million Dollar and Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum. He has a 10.0 rating from AVVO. He also serves as a Milwaukee County Court Commissioner and a board member for the Wisconsin Association for Justice.
Reviews (11)
Matthew Kiefer
Matthew Kiefer
Dec 31, 2021
Report
My experience with PKSD was good until half way threw the case, I was sent to their rehabilitation center or the place they set up for me and the process there was very sad and seemed shoddy at best. I talked to the administrator about what my injuries where and from there was given a 10-15 minute heat pad treatment once a week and one massage treatment that lasted at best 1 minute. I complained to my assigned lawyer and he did nothing and as I continued the farse at the rehab center I was offered $3,000.00 For my case I said no that wasn't good enough so the lawyer said he would see what he could
P. Engel
P. Engel
Dec 30, 2021
Report
PKSD is a "5 Star" legal practice in all respects. Without going into a lot of detail regarding the case that my family brought to PKSD, from the beginning, they gave us hope that they could obtain a level of justice to a very unfortunate incident that caused the unnecessary death of our mother. It took a while to get to a final outcome because the original insurance company literally went out of business in the middle of the process. That greatly complicated the assignment of responsibility to other personal insurances that PKSD and its negotiating partners successfully led in reaching a successful
Oceana DavidWeber
Oceana DavidWeber
Oct 28, 2021
Report
A BIG thank you to Luke Mayefske and the PKSD team! I am beyond impressed with the level of professionalism, communication, and commitment I received over the last two years. Luke advocated for me every step of the way and ensured that I received a fair and appropriate car accident settlement. Thank you for turning a such a stressful situation into a positive experience. I HIGHLY recommend Luke and PKSD to anyone in need!
What'S. Up Bri
What'S. Up Bri
Sep 30, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness
Just finished working with Luke from PKSD. They took my case after multiple lawyers wouldn’t because I didn’t call immediately. He communicated with me thoroughly, made sure to lay out expectations, and got me more than what I expected! Will definitely bring any of my future legal services here!
Jeanne
Jeanne
Sep 25, 2021
Report
I recently retained PKSD law firm for an injury. Luke Mayefske was the attorney assigned to my case. He was always professional, yet thorough in explaining the process and the progress. He respectfully invited me to weigh in on decisions. He responded in a timely manner to all my calls and emails, even when he was out of the office on personal leave. Luke obtained a good settlement without having to go to court, including a substantial reduction in medical bills, which allowed me to keep a larger portion of the settlement. The staff was always respectful, friendly and professional, right down to
Terry Schemehorn
Terry Schemehorn
Jul 30, 2021
Report
PKSD is an exceptional law firm with outstanding results. I would highly recommend Luke Mayefsk. Luke will keep things professional, keeping you informed of what is going on with your case throughout the process. He will work extremely hard for you getting you what you deserve. Everyone at PKSD is a pleasure to work with. You really should choose PKSD and you won't be disappointed.
Terry S.
Amy Tixier
Amy Tixier
Mar 12, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
My case wasn’t about money. It was keeping the responsible party accountable. Luke Mayefske was absolutely amazing. He was professional, kind, and dedicated. I am very grateful for PKSD!
Dan Defenbaugh
Dan Defenbaugh
Feb 13, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I can not say enough about my experience with all of the people at PKSD. From my initial contact to the end of the case was as pleasant as I think it could have been in an unpleasant situation. They were friendly, responsive, articulate, and understanding. I will recommend PKSD to anyone who is in need of their help. Thank you PKSD!
Paul Martell
Paul Martell
Nov 08, 2020
Report
PKSD assisted us with a settlement incurred due to an accident at a store. The results of the incident were unforeseen, however the representation from PKSD helped guide us and gain closure. I feel that they became as encompassed and understanding of the situation as all of our family members. Very pleased with their engagement and the agreed upon resolution.
Taylor Selby
Taylor Selby
Sep 03, 2020
Report
We had an outstanding experience with PKSD. They fought hard for our family all the way through the process. Jeffrey Pittman is a someone who I have grown to trust.
PKSD was highly responsive and effective. I couldn't be happier with their service. They took great care with our family in a very difficult situation.
In my experience, they are a model law firm. They treated us with respect and really went to bat for us.
Samantha P.
Samantha P.
Jul 19, 2017
Report
The paralegal and the lawyer who I worked with at PKSD were very quick to reply via email or phone call. They stepped in and took over making phone calls to billing companies so I did not have to. They kept me informed on the process and I would recommend them to someone in need of a personal injury lawyer.