Name: Highland Pizza & Ice Cream
Address: 6530 State Route 229, Marengo, OH, 43334, US
Telephone: (419) 768-3883
Rating: 4.3

Since 1992, Highland Pizza & Ice Cream has served up a full menu of Italian favorites, including signature pizzas, pasta, subs and sides, alongside a huge selection of ice cream flavors. We're your dessert shop and pizza takeout destination for family dinner, a little league celebratory outing, date night or just for delicious food, made fresh.

Carry-out, drive-thru or dine-in with us today! We've been a destination eatery since 1992 and welcome both new and returning customers for lunch and dinner. Our pizza restaurant is family-owned, dedicated to providing people with quality food and a welcoming atmosphere. If you're looking for freshly made pies in Marengo, Sparta, Chesterville, Mt Liberty, or Morrow County, OH, there's no place better than Highland Pizza & Ice Cream.

Website Update

Services

Our Menu Report

Looking for a lunch or dinner option that's convenient, affordable and delicious? Highland Pizza & Ice Cream offers a full menu of classic Italian favorites, ready for you to enjoy via carry-out, drive-thru or in our dining room. We're the perfect destination for family meals, date night, celebratory dinners and more!

If you're a resident of Marengo, Sparta, Chesterville, Mt Liberty, or Morrow County, OH or are just passing through, make sure you pull up a chair at Highland Pizza & Ice Cream for a meal you won't soon forget! We've got a full menu of favorites like pizza, pasta, and ice cream choices, ready to put a smile on your face.

Reviews (10)

Write a Review

Rob Courtney

Dec 13, 2021

Report

The Highland Sub has to be the best sandwich in Ohio. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Fantastic service: the entire staff went above and beyond when they absolutely didn't have to to make this a great visit. Very impressed!

Dustin Eades

Oct 24, 2021

Report

Stopped in while working in the area. Awesome service with a smile. Really lovely smile too! 😊 food was good and made with care. Definitely recommended!!

Ray Neighbarger

Oct 20, 2021

Report

Milk shake is just cold chocolate milk. The ice cream part my order was made 15 min before the rest was made. Staff either doesn't care or is untrained.

John Sheldon

Oct 11, 2021

Report

Love this place food is always good ! I usually get a pepperoni with extra cheese but their subs are also the bomb 💣 The staff is absolutely amazing ! Everytime I go they are super friendly and polite. Definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for a great pizza or sub !!

Jayson Waits

Sep 11, 2021

Report

Have stopped here in the past while passing through for ice cream. This was first time getting lunch and ate outside. Food was really good especially my pizza. Of course we topped it off with ice cream!

Howard Shaw

Aug 24, 2021

Report

The pizza and subs are definitely fresh. You can taste the difference in the food. My wife abd and I really like it and have been back already.

Laura Shepherd

Jul 29, 2021

Report

Small, side of the road ice cream stand. Workers were kind. They seemed new. Good ice cream. We did not try the food. But they had several drive through food pick-ups while we were there. Picnic tables outside for eating.

Jaredo O.

Jul 16, 2021

Report

I'm a huge pineapple-on-pizza guy, and one of the ways I test a pizza place is by trying out their Hawaiian. For a long time I considered Donatos Hawaiian as the absolute best, but holy $%#& Highland Pizza knows how to make a Hawaiian. I'm extremely eager to try out everything else they offer, but for right now I'd recommend Highland over Donatos!

Tammy Kochis

Apr 25, 2021

Report

Been here several times before, but never had pizza until today. What a fool! From Cleveland area and LOVE their pizza!! Perfect crust! Sausage and pepperoni great flavor, and do you see how much is on this pizza!?! Sauce is very good and the cheese was delicious and stringy. Will make sure not to miss them again

Tracie Saunders

Feb 12, 2021

Report

We try to eat from local small businesses especially when we travel. We found this place on google,and our pizza was fresh and hot,made JUST as we had ordered. We were greeted by friendly people there,and the place was very clean. And oh my gosh was it ever so delicious!! I highly recommend this place. Their ice cream was also delicious by the way!