Penny Realty
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Penny Realty
When it comes to San Diego Property Management and Rentals, look no further than Penny Realty. Since 1965, we have been one of the most trusted Property Management Companies in the Greater San Diego Area. We provide full service Property Solutions for Owners, Investors and Residents. Our primary and only focus is the delivery of "exceptional service" to all our Clients.

Since 1965, Penny Realty has provided World Class Service to the San Diego County Property Management Industry. Our proven Property Management Systems have provided hundreds of Landlords with peace of mind and profitable results. On average, Penny Realty rents vacant properties in 11 days! Not only do we rent fast, but we also rent to high quality Residents.
Services
At Penny Realty, our objective is to generate maximum returns for San Diego Property Owners and Investors, saving them time and money while still providing our residents with a fantastic renting experience. We operate with a high degree of transparency and professionalism, always making sure that our goals and profitability are properly aligned with our clients here in the greater San Diego area.
Penny Realty, Inc. has been an established leader in Single Family Home and Multifamily Property Management since 1965. We recognize that your rental property is a very valuable asset. You can entrust the management of that asset to an organization with a long trusted history that offers you peace of mind.
If we are unable to lease your Home in 14 days or less, we will provide your first TWO months of property management free! The 14 days start when the Home is ready and in move-in condition and the photography is completed. At Penny Realty, we take great pride in the selection of high quality Residents.
Shayne Flaherty, Owner and Vice President of Penny Realty, has invited the heads and representatives of five of the contractors that Penny Realty works with in delivering services to the property owners in the company's portfolio.

Watch as Shayne conducts a quick interview with Eric Nunes, the representative for sales at Bonded Flooring; Tom Kennedy, the President of Kennedy Electric; Nicholas and Damian Desantis, President and Vice President of Desantis Renovation Solutions, respectively; Dale Fornta, Operations Manager of C&C Glass; and Beau Crow, President of AGP Plumbing.
Penny Realty, Inc., has been in business in San Diego since 1965. We have steadily grown to become the premier full-service Coastal Real Estate Office offering Vacation Rentals, Long Term Rentals, and a unique Hybrid Rental option with a month long term rental combined with weekly Summer Rentals. Penny Realty has an outstanding variety of Homes, Condos, and Multifamily Apartments all of which come with our Exceptional Service Guarantee.
Reviews (24)
Sally Doyle
Sally Doyle
Jan 26, 2022
Report
I approached Greg Flaherty, owner of Penny Realty, with questions about renting my apartment. He took the time to listen to my needs and visited the property. Penny Realty uses a wide range of resources to find the right tenant. Always friendly and professional. It was rented within the month!
It was Veronica Nave, the account manager, who found the tenant and did a fantastic job of helping to finalize the lease.
Austin L.
Austin L.
Jan 13, 2022
Report
I've worked with Aleesa from Penny Realty for 2 years now and have nothing but good things to say. Always responsive, clear, and looking to help in any way she can. I just hope all my agents are as great as Aleesa.
Debra Jorgensen
Debra Jorgensen
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I can't say enough about Penny Realty! From our initial meeting with Greg to our dealings with Veronica, they are top notch! Very professional and responsive. Answered every question I had quickly. Veronica went well beyond the level of service I was expecting. 5 Stars!
Christiana L.
Christiana L.
Jan 04, 2022
Report
I had a great experience working with Aleesa at penny realty. Aleesa really prioritizes her applicants and tries to find the right fit for each client and each property. Will definitely be recommending and working with them in the future!
Katherine Tartaglia
Katherine Tartaglia
Jan 04, 2022
Report
I can't imagine working with a better property management company. We have worked with companies in the past that are sub par and working with Camryn and Penny Realty has been a breath of fresh air. Any questions are answered quickly all instructions are clear and easy to follow. In summary, Penny Realty makes things seamless for their tenants and owners. Camryn has guided us through the whole rental process with fantastic customer service and its been a pleasure working with her.
Olivia Hughes
Olivia Hughes
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Penny Realty is the property management company that we rent from. They really make the onboarding process east for tenants. My partner and I work with Aleesa and she has been wonderful. She's super friendly and very responsive. I'd highly recommend using them as a property management company or renting from their listings online! 10/10
Ethan S.
Ethan S.
Dec 06, 2021
Report
Penny Realty has been fantastic at helping with home rentals and home purchases. The whole team is super helpful throughout the entire process. Greg, Cherene, Aleesa, Veronica and James are a great team to have behind you, and I'm sure there are others working behind the scenes.
Stephen Howell
Stephen Howell
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Veronica at Penny Realty has been an absolute pleasure to work with. She is professional, experienced, and super timely on getting things accomplished. Our experience with everyone else at Penny, from the owner, Greg, who visited our home for the initial consult, to the receptionist has been excellent as well. I would highly recommend.
Boryana Vasileva
Boryana Vasileva
Nov 24, 2021
Report
Penny Realty helped us rent out our house recently. Originally, we had chosen a different rental management company and we are so happy we switched to Penny Realty. Veronica, the person in charge of residential real estate, has been a pleasure to work with. Veronica and the team have been professional, courteous, and rented our house in 1 day for more than we had expected. We strongly recommend Penny Realty!
Nick L.
Nick L.
Nov 12, 2021
Report
Penny Realty has been great for managing our property. Great communication and highly efficient.. Veronica and her team were able to get our home listed and rented very quickly. Highly recommend if you are looking for property management.
Amy T.
Amy T.
Oct 08, 2021
Report
Rented an apartment and had Aleesa help me out. She responds promptly and is so friendly and made the whole process so easy! Maintenance requests were taken care of quickly as well
Christian P.
Christian P.
Sep 23, 2021
Report
We had a great stay at our rental! It was very clean and very well stocked! We really were surprised how well the kitchen was stocked (they even had coffee filters for the coffee maker...and the coffee maker was clean).
They were really responsive when we had a question. We definitely would be booking again!
Tyler P.
Tyler P.
Aug 16, 2021
Report
For someone who was struggling to find a place to rent, Penny Reality went above and beyond to help me find what I was looking for. Veronica, who managed my rental, was very communicative the entire process and never left me out in the dark with anything. She responded to all my questions and was always very professional and friendly. I 100% recommend Penny Reality to anyone and would strongly suggest asking for Veronica.
James P.
James P.
Aug 03, 2021
Report
As the former owner of a residential property management company I can only say that I wish Camryn had worked with me. I had an issue that was my fault she handled the incident with amazing tact and understanding. She represented her owners interest while still treating me fairly.

Camryn is an all-star.
Justin V.
Justin V.
Jul 29, 2021
Report
Aleesa is awesome! Thank you so much for getting me a great place, walking me through the application process and going above and beyond to get me in my new place.
Aloha
Kati L.
Kati L.
Jun 21, 2021
Report
This is a great beach bungalow for our vacation - right on Mission bay, enough room for 3 adults and a toddler to live comfortably for a week. Its walking distance to several cute coffee shops/ restaurants in Mission Beach. You'll love!
Shirley Noriega
Shirley Noriega
Jun 19, 2021
Report
Thank you so much for your awesome service!. Both you and Cherene were a delight to work with and very quick in handling the check in issue with the garage opener.  The whole process was quick and easy. The house was beautiful and the view is amazing. I loved waking up and making breakfast to the view of the ocean! I definitely will keep penny realty in mind for our future vacations!
Joanne A.
Joanne A.
Jun 03, 2021
Report
Forward our continued relationship!

Your Review: We rented the house because
our daughter was graduating from the University of San Diego. The house was absolutely perfect for our needs. Very clean and comfortable. The location is ideal, walking distance to either the beach or bay side. Yet the neighborhood is so quaint and quiet. The outdoor space is ideal and has nice furniture, where we spent a lot of time. We ate meals outside and used the grill and outdoor heater. Everything was very well appointed! We already talked of returning!
Lance O.
Lance O.
May 27, 2021
Report
False statement by the company owner follow up. We had 3 illegal tenants in our very expensive 5 br house near the beach, with an illegal dog that also damaged the property. The tenants were served a 3 day notice to remove the 3 illegal tenants and illegal dog... refused to do so and then Penny Realty asked for us to allow them to keep the party house going with our furnished family house. Penny Realty refused to evict, with no Covid protection to the tenants that were all in their 20's.

There was over $10k in damage to our house, and they still haven't paid their utility bills
Ana M.
Ana M.
May 18, 2021
Report
Superior customer service. I called to check in on an application I had submitted, someone actually answered AND followed up with me. While I was not the right match for that rental, they explained that my application fee was refunded!! I truly appreciate that this is a company standard.
Brianna P.
Brianna P.
Apr 15, 2021
Report
We really enjoyed this property! It was right next to the beach (cove) and across the street from the main beach (Mission Beach). It is within walking distance of the jet ski, boat, kayak, etc rentals. All kitchen appliances and tv worked. The wifi wasn't great, so we didn't stay connected to it. There is no real "front door" since the entrance is through the main bedroom or through the sliding door, but that wasn't an issue for us. We were able to check in after hours with their system so that was great! Checkout was easy. Really enjoyed and would recommend.
Katherine W.
Katherine W.
Apr 06, 2021
Report
I rented one of their Ocean Beach, SD properties. My review of the house is below. Working with Penny Realty was a breeze! They were very responsive, answered all my questions, easy to work with, no issues or surprises.

Loved this beach house! I came with my family and it was perfect. There is a ground floor bedroom with walk-in shower that is good for any older people, and suited my 94 year old grandma very well. The other bedrooms are upstairs. The main dining area, living area and downstairs patio has direct views of the sand and waves. We were worried that grandma wouldn't be able to
Heather K.
Heather K.
Mar 15, 2021
Report
Amazing location and beautiful condo. Very helpful with quick responses and recommendations on things to do
Val W.
Val W.
Mar 10, 2021
Report
Had a great stay in Ocean Beach. They were responsive to any emails. Directions to parking at first could've been clearer, but otherwise all went well.