While we are still enjoying the journey, we have decided to modify the hotel operations to a 'bed & breakfast' beginning in the Spring of 2022 - which means - our restaurant will remain open through New Year's Eve, 2021. If you would like to enjoy dinner or Sunday Brunch with us, there is still plenty of time to do so.
We (Doug & Garth) will continue to run the hotel as innkeepers, so we hope you will keep us in your travel plans as you are all such cherished friends to us. As you know, the hotel is for sale & it is our plan to operate as a 'rooms only' business until that special buyer is found (and yes, Garth will still be on board to make you a delicious breakfast)!
We (Doug & Garth) will continue to run the hotel as innkeepers, so we hope you will keep us in your travel plans as you are all such cherished friends to us. As you know, the hotel is for sale & it is our plan to operate as a 'rooms only' business until that special buyer is found (and yes, Garth will still be on board to make you a delicious breakfast)!
Services
The American Hotel makes every effort to support local farming. We believe that one of the most important ways to support your community is to support its farms. Here is a list of just a few farms and local purveyors who work year round to provide us with the safest, freshest and healthiest food that we are often able to offer our guests.
Our largest first floor guest room (ADA compliant and pet-friendly) offers first floor porch and lobby access, queen bed, private bath. Situated at the north end of the hotel's 2nd floor, this quiet corner room includes a queen bed, private bath. Located on the 2nd floor and providing two twin sized beds with an ample dresser in between, this corner room overlooks the back of the hotel, private bath.
Reviews (25)
Robin Greer-Jogun
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Loretta Branigan
Oct 31, 2021
Report
Fran T.
Oct 11, 2021
Report
Ive always loved this place however, yesterdays brunch was not up to par.the eggs benedict was not acceptable.both eggs were cooked almost to hard boil.no creamy yellow yolk running from the eggs.potates were cold and we both had about 6 to 8 on our plate.waitress was not attentive and never asked us if we needed anything or if our food was ok.another waitress finally stopped by so we could have refills on our coffee as we were eating breakfast.i understand good help is scarce right now however we are paying customers and deserve better.as i said,i was always happy with the food there but not this
Justin J. Miller
Sep 29, 2021
Report
Michael Lambert
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Elizabeth Lerner
Jul 30, 2021
Report
Pamela B.
Jul 20, 2021
Report
The American Hotel is a dining experience amidst a small rural farming community. You will be made to feel at home and comfortable and yet treated to a fine dining experience without pretentiousness. Owners, maitre d', waitstaff and kitchen staff are all friendly, professional and fun.
A worthwhile experience wether looking for a full course dining experience in your finest designer wear or a casual pub menu delight on your way home from the lake in your shorts and docksiders.
A worthwhile experience wether looking for a full course dining experience in your finest designer wear or a casual pub menu delight on your way home from the lake in your shorts and docksiders.
Brad Decker
Jul 04, 2021
Report
Linda M.
Jun 11, 2021
Report
Joseph Walchko
May 19, 2021
Report
Brett K.
Apr 26, 2021
Report
Jen Carangi
Dec 11, 2020
Report
I didn't lodge here this review is for the restaurant.
Quaint, cozy dining experience in a historic atmosphere. Inn/restaurant embraces the history of Sharon Springs. Staff was friendly and helpful. Beautiful decor. Ordered a burger, was the best burger I've ever had. Perfectly cooked, juicy, large, and tasty. Thanks guys, keep up the great work.
Quaint, cozy dining experience in a historic atmosphere. Inn/restaurant embraces the history of Sharon Springs. Staff was friendly and helpful. Beautiful decor. Ordered a burger, was the best burger I've ever had. Perfectly cooked, juicy, large, and tasty. Thanks guys, keep up the great work.
Sonni Gallagher
Sep 04, 2020
Report
The service was excellent. I had the trio sampler plate...the deep fried cheese was perfect...the shrimp cocktail was okay except the cocktail sauce was watery and no flavor and the crab cake was not hot. My husband had the pork dinner...large portion, tender which is great...the food seemed reheated and not hot the mushroom gravy was delightful. My roasted beet salad was perfect.
Cheryl Z.
Feb 15, 2020
Report
Wow, first time there for a surprise Valentines dinner and they were busy but we had a phenomenal meal. We had a Sampler appetizer that could be a meal. It was amazing. 2 fabulous crab cakes, 4 shrimp cocktail and 2 beer battered cheese balls served with chunked cooked apples! The combo was pretty mind blowing !! Salads came out on cold plates and our dinners of steak and lobster were wonderful. We took home our dessert of a deconstructed chocolate dessert that was chocolate chip cookie and chocolate mousse. I believe the chocolate mouse may have been made with coconut milk which added a whole
Anne Marie W.
Jan 12, 2020
Report
Guys, yum. They had opened the dining room for lunch because of the Schitt's Creek pop-up happening across the street at Beekman 1802. And we're so glad they did! I had a shrimp and lobster enchiladas and could not get over the deliciousness. Huge chucks of shrimp and lobster, flavorful sauce, dollop of sour cream, and micro greens. A nice rose on the side. Worth the drive!
Mariah H.
Oct 19, 2019
Report
I can only review the food, I just stopped in for lunch after a day trip to the area to check out Beekman 1802 across the street, but the meal I had was easily yummy enough to convince me to stay at this hotel if only for the proximity to an excellent menu.
The hotel is adorable, loved the atmosphere. The menu isn't gigantic, but I also appreciate that. I'm usually overwhelmed when there are too many options. I had the street corn salad for lunch with grilled chicken (another option was shrimp). It was INCREDIBLE. So incredible I immediately set to try and recreate the recipe when I
The hotel is adorable, loved the atmosphere. The menu isn't gigantic, but I also appreciate that. I'm usually overwhelmed when there are too many options. I had the street corn salad for lunch with grilled chicken (another option was shrimp). It was INCREDIBLE. So incredible I immediately set to try and recreate the recipe when I
Timothy R.
Jun 17, 2019
Report
This review is for the American Hotel Restaurant and NOT the lodging. Is there a separate Yelp entry for only the restaurant? If so, I'll move this review.
Food for old people. Not much else to it.
None of the flavors popped and gave me that "oh, this is good" buzz. And that's what I'm looking for in any restaurant outside fast food -- if they expect repeat business. Oddly, the french fries, what I consider 'bar food' was the best in category out of the three entrees and accompanying soup/salads I sampled. I really wanted to like the place after reading
Food for old people. Not much else to it.
None of the flavors popped and gave me that "oh, this is good" buzz. And that's what I'm looking for in any restaurant outside fast food -- if they expect repeat business. Oddly, the french fries, what I consider 'bar food' was the best in category out of the three entrees and accompanying soup/salads I sampled. I really wanted to like the place after reading
Janet M.
Nov 16, 2018
Report
What a spectacular experience. Located in the charming village of Sharon Springs, owners Doug Plummer and Garth Roberts (whom we didn't get to meet, but assume that he's equally fabulous) were gracious, generous and delightful. Beautifully restored and furnished, the American Hotel is the perfect getaway. Filled with historic artifacts, it's wonderful to see the once grand lady restored with care and attention to detail. Breakfast was very, very good...I had homemade granola with Greek yogurt and sliced strawberries and my husband had a very tasty omelette. When a snowstorm closed
Julie B.
Oct 07, 2018
Report
This is probably one of my favorite places in the region and has been a huge impetus for improvement in the last couple of decades. Not only is the setting absolutely gorgeous, the food and hospitality are more than worth your while.
Despite it being early October, we were able to sit on the back patio next to the Japanese zen fountain overlooking the lush, green yard in the back. The interior is fully restored with a lot of care to historic detail and features unique art old and new from local makers.
The dining room is more formal but the bar and sitting area are casual and laid-back so it
Despite it being early October, we were able to sit on the back patio next to the Japanese zen fountain overlooking the lush, green yard in the back. The interior is fully restored with a lot of care to historic detail and features unique art old and new from local makers.
The dining room is more formal but the bar and sitting area are casual and laid-back so it
Nelson B.
Sep 17, 2018
Report
We were here for the special 2018 Harvest Feast at the hotel which ends the Sharon Springs Harvest Festival and features produce from local farms. This year featured Sunnycrest Orchards and it's craft vinegars. Sharon Springs' Mayor was Master of Ceremonies for the evening. Each course was introduced by Laurie or Tim Schilde of Sunnycrest, each featured a craft vinegar prep and each was unique: from the Sweet Pepper and Chicken Gumbo to Green Tomato Salad to Pork Rouladen to a desert of poached apple w/ice cream and honey citrus gastrique. This was truly one of the most interesting and
Nick G.
Jul 29, 2018
Report
Waiting for my corn cakes with maple syrup and bacon breakfast. Coffee is excellent and this the design of this place is cozy.
Wow!!! Awesome flavor and came out hot and delicious.
Back for a second time (we live in Florida). Let me just say that if you are within 30 minutes of the American Hotel, drive over for breakfast and order the Corn Cakes, you will be amazed.
Wow!!! Awesome flavor and came out hot and delicious.
Back for a second time (we live in Florida). Let me just say that if you are within 30 minutes of the American Hotel, drive over for breakfast and order the Corn Cakes, you will be amazed.
PVallegria H.
May 27, 2018
Report
Fred I.
Jul 29, 2017
Report
Excellent food, service and atmosphere in the heart of rural upstate NY. Went here on a Sunday for the second time in the past year. Good time to go between noon and 2:00 PM, because you can choose from either the Brunch menu (8:00 AM - 2:00 PM) or the Sunday Afternoon Meals menu (11:30 AM to 4:00 PM)...... double the choices ! ! !
Trying to remember all our meals.... Pan Seared Salmon for Ms. I, I had "beef hash" special of the day (large chunks of rare tenderloin, small potatoes, peppers, onions.... mmmmm), our (adult) son had the strip steak and eggs (perfectly cooked), and his
Trying to remember all our meals.... Pan Seared Salmon for Ms. I, I had "beef hash" special of the day (large chunks of rare tenderloin, small potatoes, peppers, onions.... mmmmm), our (adult) son had the strip steak and eggs (perfectly cooked), and his
Gary P.
Jul 06, 2017
Report
Mike P.
Jan 05, 2017
Report
I'm not quite sure why I've never been here to eat, given we live close and have been to the Bistro numerous times. This is a very good place to eat. Between the bistro down the street and The American Hotel, Sharon springs has by far the best eating in the county. Both of these places are reasons to not drive to Albany for a good dinner.
The food was excellent. Definitely try the poutine, I do wish there had been a tiny bit more gravy and the cheese curd was not as cold so it had melted a little more but that's a minor complaint because the meat was cooked perfectly. Everything
The food was excellent. Definitely try the poutine, I do wish there had been a tiny bit more gravy and the cheese curd was not as cold so it had melted a little more but that's a minor complaint because the meat was cooked perfectly. Everything