McNicholas Realtors
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Use this area to search by minimum or maximum price, # of bedrooms, # of baths, square footage, MLS #'s, or any of dozens of parameters you choose. What is the IABS? Texas law requires all brokers and sales agents to provide written notice regarding information about brokerage services at the first substantive communication with prospective buyers, tenants, sellers, and landlordsconcerning specific real property.

The Information About Brokerage Servicesform(or the IABS) is the required method to provide that information to those parties. This web site features every real estate tool you need.
Services
Do you have general San Antonio real estate requests or need a Realtor to represent you in other surrounding Bexar, Comal, Guadalupe County areas? Please fill out the following general real estate request form. Tell me a little bit about how I can help you. Thanks again and all inquiries will be responded to in a timely fashion.
Search homes for sale or lease as well as other real estate opportunities in surrounding areas. Feel free to call as well if you have questions. Once we find properties that match what you are looking for, we will contact you to give you detailed information, pictures and answer all your questions.
If you are looking for the perfect San Antonio or New Braunfels area home, you've come to the right place. Please note that there is no obligation and your information will be kept strictly confidential. Either Peg or Christina will contact you with the initial results of the home search in the local real estate market.
You can customize a search for propeties for lease, searching by number or bedrooms, price range and/or amenities as well as communities or schools you may prefer. View photos as well.

Any School ,C all District ,C uero Isd ,F air Oaks Ranch ,F rankston ,H erff ,H unt Allison Bagdad Baldwin Barron, Wieland Elementary Bartlett Barton Creek Bee Cave Benjamin Doc Kerley Elementary Bertram Bill Brown Bill Burden Blanton Brentwood Bridge Point Brown Primary Bryker Woods Camacho Camino Real Campbell Canyon Creek Carpenter Hill Casey CC Mason Clayton Clear Spring Colt Cook Cowan Cunningham Dawson Dearing Deep Wood Dell Pickett, Wolf Ranch Doss (Austin Isd) Double File Trail Eanes Elm Grove Emile Fern Bluff Gattis Giddings Govalle Great Oaks Haynes Hemphill Hernandez Herrington, Double File Trl.
We have successfully managed residential rental properties for 35 years. We have a proven track record. Peg's philosophy is clearly stated, I personally manage each home as if it were my very own home, carefully qualifying each tenant, advising each owner on the market and repairs as if I were spending my own money.
Reviews (8)
Philip Layton
Philip Layton
Jan 20, 2022
Report
I’ve been in the military for over 10 years and have rented the entire time and this is by far the WORST company I have ever worked with. No communication from Becky when we were moving out had to call the actual landlord to get answers and to have her contact us back. Took 2.5 months to get the deposit back and when we received the deposit (they made us turn keys in and did their own inspection without us there) it was less than half of the deposit for repairs we were never told of and that were there when we moved in. I have never not received my full deposit back but this is the first. Most
Britney Simpson
Britney Simpson
Jul 15, 2021
Report
If I could give a zero for my rating I would. Rebecca Kelly was not the ideal agent I wanted to conduct business with. Upon contacting her and leaving voicemails, emails she didn’t do a great job at responding to them or getting back to me. I found her to be unprofessional and rude when I spoke with her to inquire about a property I was interested in renting that had been on the market for 20 days, she claimed there were 3 applicants already. However, I was informed previously that there were none but based on Rebeccas tone and attitude she clearly was not trying to service me so i would not
John Ensley
John Ensley
Dec 26, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I rented from McNicholas Realtors for 2 years. The AC went out and was fixed within 24 hours. Any time we brought concerns to Peg she scheduled maintenance promptly. We returned the house as found, and received our full deposit back. The house wasn't perfect, but was priced accordingly, so I was happy with the experience.
Janet Foy
Janet Foy
Jun 09, 2020
Report
Would not recommend.
Listed a home that we sold after managing a rental that we owned.
“They” approved a $1000 A/C repair and NEVER told us about the charge. Not in text or email... nothing. We happened to see the charge on the final settlement statement AT CLOSING.
It was then explained that they made an executive decision since they didn’t think they could reach us since we were on a cruise. I was reachable while on the cruise and my husband wasn’t on the cruise. Very much reachable. Didn’t even attempt.
THEN they explained that they were charging worse case unexplainable “final”
Vernon Rowe
Vernon Rowe
Jan 09, 2020
Report
We leased a house from Mc Nicholas Realtors in New Braunfels for two years. We never met anyone from the company during that two years. All of our business with them was conducted over the phone or by text or e-mail. During that time the company sent an A/C tech out twice a year to check the heating & cooling units. (they always called and made arrangements for us to be at home). We had a thermostat go bad on the range and when we called to report it, they sent out a repairman the next day.
When we decided to relocate, we were required to give a 30 day notice. As I was searching for their company
Susan Moore
Susan Moore
Sep 17, 2019
Report
I leased from McNicholas Realtors for four years and I found them to be very responsive, professional and available for my problems if I had any. Peggy is very helpful and Becky is very knowledgeable. I would recommend them to anyone!!
Melchor Villarreal
Melchor Villarreal
Aug 15, 2019
Report
We rented a property from McNicholas Realtors for three years and were very happy with the service that we received. Peg and Becky were very easy to contact as they are available by phone, text message, or email. They responded very quickly to our concerns and they sent professionals to our home to repair our problems. We received a prompt refund of our security deposit when we left the home. We are very grateful to Peg and Becky for all that they did.
Ashley Westgate
Ashley Westgate
Aug 08, 2019
Report
Avoid this "business" at all cost, there are plenty of other better-rated realtors in the San Antonio area. My husband and I were active duty military looking for a home to rent in Texas while still stationed in California. We were on a tight time frame to find a large home to rent without having the opportunity to look at the home first. I found a home to rent on their website and the application process was fast and easy...that's the only good part... Once you sign the rental agreement they forget who you are. We had multiple problems with the home once we moved in- garage doors not opening,