Step into our warm, welcoming storefront and bask in the scent of freshly baked breads of all varieties. From down-home sandwich breads to hearty ryes, there's something here that's sure to please. Our time-tested, from scratch recipe is the best around. Layer upon layer of your favorite flavors, our cakes are baked today, by real people, using real ingredients and never any preservatives.
Forget about everything you think you know about donuts. Our delectable breakfast favorites are hand-cut daily and prepared by master bakers with decades of experience. Everyone's weak spot, right? We offer the best selection of all of your favorites, including Napoleons, Cream Puffs, Eclairs, Sour Cream Dainties, and more.
Forget about everything you think you know about donuts. Our delectable breakfast favorites are hand-cut daily and prepared by master bakers with decades of experience. Everyone's weak spot, right? We offer the best selection of all of your favorites, including Napoleons, Cream Puffs, Eclairs, Sour Cream Dainties, and more.
Services
Experience the quaint, welcoming atmosphere and the tantalizing aromas as you enter our storefront. You'll feel like you've stepped back in time - an era where customer service mattered and the recipes are time-tested and traditional. The sights and scents will warm your heart and our products will delight your taste buds.
Keystone Bakery is proud to be associated with so many fine establishments in the area. We have been delivering our wares to restaurants, delis, pizza shops and grocery stores for many years. We have reaped the reward of many repeat customers through our ability to service our wholesale accounts with specialized products combined with our timely and superior service.
What birthday girl or boy is going to be satisfied with a so-so cake from a so-so bakery? Not our kids and that's for sure! We'd never be able to pass off any baked good that didn't come from the Keystone Bakery and that's why you should make Keystone Bakery a part of your special occasion from this moment on.
Keystone Bakery is a locally owned and operated bakery committed to providing our customers with consistently high-quality bakery products and responsive, personal customer service. Our team is passionate about our high standards and commitment to each and every customer. We strive to exceed customer expectations in an effort to increase customer loyalty.
Reviews (13)
Virginia P.
Oct 30, 2021
Report
Katy H.
Jan 18, 2021
Report
I would advise everyone who is trying to be careful of their health avoid this bakery. I just drove three hours from Columbus to visit this place because I grew up eating bunker hills at my grandma's house from this place. But I went in, and was greeted pleasantly by the you lady at the front, but another elderly woman was walking around the place coughing all over everything with the worst cough I've ever had. She coughed on the pierogi, she coughed on the counters. It was awful to listen to and be near. If we hadn't driven so far I would have turned around and left. I left two
Alice H.
Jul 12, 2020
Report
Pat K.
Jun 23, 2020
Report
Krista W.
Jun 02, 2019
Report
Shirley T.
Jan 08, 2019
Report
I'd been on a job in Arnold City for 3 months and only found this place during the final week! So sad, but I tried to try as many items as possible! They have a great selection of pastries, breads, and desserts. I think my favorite of the things I tried were the apple donut (so fluffy and light and delicious!) and pineapple filled cookie. The goods all are very fresh and seem to be prepared by hand. For special occasions/groups, they also carry full cakes and pies. Plus, they offer coffee in the store as well! It's easy to miss tucked in a plaza, but worth a trip if you're in the
Karla D.
Jun 26, 2017
Report
Raynelle P.
Dec 08, 2016
Report
Malary J.
Jun 25, 2016
Report
A. C.
Apr 03, 2015
Report
Eric D.
Aug 04, 2014
Report
Keystone Bakery is one of my favorite places to visit when I am back in the BVA. While the bakery changed hands a few years ago you really can't tell a difference, which is a good thing.
Atmosphere - Sweet smells, busy, narrow room, with clean and basic decorating as to not detract from the large glass counter/ case of tasty pastries.
Food - My favorites items here include the pecan rolls, Bunker hill rolls, Paska bread, dinner rolls, raisin bread, apricot Kolache, and walnut Kolache. Oh, and of course I like their cake. I like it in sheet form with the marble batter and white icing
Atmosphere - Sweet smells, busy, narrow room, with clean and basic decorating as to not detract from the large glass counter/ case of tasty pastries.
Food - My favorites items here include the pecan rolls, Bunker hill rolls, Paska bread, dinner rolls, raisin bread, apricot Kolache, and walnut Kolache. Oh, and of course I like their cake. I like it in sheet form with the marble batter and white icing
Amy C.
May 17, 2014
Report
Keystone has been a family favorite for years. Our b-day cakes always came from there and they were always so cool with everything from a Cabbage Patch Kid doll to The Hulk to The Smurfs (I was a child of the 80's you know:)!). They have added a location in Greensburg. Nice and a little bigger than the BV location but still the same awesome sweet treats. I love their icing however if you don't like sweet, stay away from the cake because their icing is sweet. It definitely suits me to a tee because I love sweet. Cookies are great too. Like the strawberry logs as well. Hubby likes the
Megan F.
Mar 24, 2014
Report
