Name: Martino's Pizzeria
Address: 160 W Main St, Webster, NY, 14580, US
Telephone: (585) 872-4140
Rating: 3.88

Martino's Pizzeria has been proudly serving the Webster/Penfield area for over 40 years! Owner, Abel, strives to bring new ideas and flavors to the menu while also preserving the classic, old-world feel of the pizzeria and taste of the authentic, homemade Italian food.

From our fresh made sub rolls and focaccia bread to homemade soups and pasta dinners to our award-winning pizza crust and sauce, we use fresh ingredients to make the tastiest food for our customers.Place an order for take-out or delivery or stop by for lunch or dinner to taste the food yourself. You will be pleasantly surprised and satisfied!

Website Update

Reviews (25)

Write a Review

Alexys Pentycofe

Nov 23, 2021

Report

Was good, middle of the pizza seemed like it needed to be cooked longer. Crust was the best part!

Paul H.

Oct 10, 2021

Report

Ordered a medium pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was amateur hour in terms of construction, and the wings were rubbery, foul tasting and inedible. The first time I ever trashed leftover wings. Martinis... One-&-Done..

Keith Crossley

Jun 05, 2021

Report

I've stopped a couple of times lately for a slice. Really good, closer to Jersey pizza than other local brands. They have a full menu s I'll be back to try that.

Megan D.

Apr 24, 2021

Report

Hooray! I recently moved to Webster ... tried just about every pizza place here. Martino's is by far the best. We had a pizza, garlic bread sticks, chicken fingers, & mozzarella sticks. I honestly loved everything! So excited to find an amazing pizza place right down the street!

Mark N.

Feb 10, 2021

Report

I will start off by saying that this place was not my first choice to order dinner tonight, but I'm so glad that my first choice took 10 minutes to get to me, then said they are no longer accepting orders for the night. So I call this place and get some wings and a Margherita pizza. Absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Whenever I get back into the area, I'll be back. Thanks a bunch!

Raj Marathe

Jan 01, 2021

Report

Stopped there recently after I discovered they were still around. Last time I had them was over 20+ years ago. Their meatball sub was excellent and just as wonderful as I remember it. I will be back next time I'm out that way. Best meatball sub in the area.

Amy W.

Dec 13, 2020

Report

I've eaten there twice. First time it was okay, good customer service. Pizza sauce was a bit too sweet for me. Second time, I was extremely hungry and would've eaten just about anything. I ate my pizza slice in the car (covid) and again sauce was too sweet.. but what really turned me off was I bit into a hard white plastic object, mid way in, I was hoping maybe it was part of an ingredient lid.. either was I wasn't impressed & lost my appetite. I will probably not visit this pizza joint again.

Vincent L.

Mar 26, 2020

Report

Excellent local pizza in the Webster village area. Got the arancini last night they were outstanding definitely a must order every time. Pizza is excellent too I mean ya can't go wrong on this menu so far in these trying times of viruses just go local get some great za and big balls of fried rice and cheese and watch a bunch of reruns of the office or always sunny in Philadelphia it's fine we're gonna make it!

Katie Yarlett

Jan 07, 2020

Report

Tonight my family ordered dinner from Martino's at 6:26 pm according to the time stamp on my phone call. I was told it would be delivered in 45 minutes. I called again at 7:40 pm as it was well over an hour in delivery. The girl answering the phone told me it had just left. I called back at 7:55 when my order still hadn't arrived. The girl on the phone was very pleasant and apologetic. She asked if I wanted to speak to a manager. I said yes. The manager, who said his name was Jericho, answered the phone and was incredibly rude to me. I had him on speaker and my husband couldn't believe the rude

Cassie M.

Oct 20, 2019

Report

Amazing service and food! I had them cater a big party of mine and I was extremely impressed by the quality and quantity of the food, as well as the service. I highly recommend this place! The owner and his wife go above
and beyond to make their customers happy!

Kiley Staats

Oct 18, 2019

Report

One of my crews favorite places for pizza in Rochester when we are in Webster filming. Took my wife here today to try the Foccacia sandwiches on a recommendation, and they were amazing.
They make the Foccacia fresh daily! I did the Floretine, and my wife had the chicken parmesan. Both were amazing.

Guy R.

Oct 17, 2019

Report

Very good pizza. It's cheaper then the big chain places. It's on the thinner side with a sweeter sauce. They don't skimp on toppings. Always friendly service. Probably my second favorite pizza place in Webster behind Carls, but they're open Monday when Carls isn't.

Songbird C.

Aug 30, 2019

Report

We are from NJ, use to thin light crust, Ny city style pies! This is the best and closest to home taste pizza in the Webster area by FAR! We order ours thin, and are so happy with it! Probably have tried every pizza join in town to find this gem! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🍕 The servic is great too!

Lindsey T.

Jul 18, 2019

Report

Seriously awesome pizza! When you ask for extra cheese you GET extra cheese!! The Caesar salad was a bit disappointing but the pizza more than up for it. Delivery took a while but the delivery person was very nice.

Wajhie H.

Feb 11, 2019

Report

Awful wait times and the menu prices are incorrect. The stuffed pizza was either overcharged by new employees or the menu doesn't list its price correctly. The pizza itself was disgustingly soggy. The wait time was quoted for 25 minutes but ended up being over an hour, which is okay but the lack of honesty wasn't.

Cathie Latoy

Jul 04, 2018

Report

The focaccia bread sandwiches are delicious! The pizza dough was very tasty, even though it is on the thin side, it wasn't dry at all. We loved the grilled chicken and meatballs. Very flavorful. We will return to savor the flavors!

Keri F.

Jul 02, 2018

Report

So the pizza is okay. It's not really anything special and stands pretty much at the same rate as most pizza places in Webster. I would order again from them for sure... the prices are good and like I said, the pizza is okay, but this has definitely not become my go-to place.

Tia D.

Jun 13, 2018

Report

Great pizza and food at great prices! The NY style pizza had a great crunch and the sauce is to die for. The service could be worked on but overall a great place!

Anthony G.

Apr 09, 2018

Report

Needed a quick bite to eat before heading to work on a Monday afternoon and there's nothin better than walking into a pizza spot that has a dollar cheese slice on Monday's and Tuesday. Sat down and enjoyed my slice while watching tv for about 10 minutes and then I was on my way.

Stevie G.

Feb 03, 2017

Report

Their bread was SO fresh and soft. I can not get over how good it tasted. Tons of meat on my sub.

Megan H.

Oct 16, 2016

Report

Well, I'll be darned! Who knew this random pizzeria in webster would be any good! I always drove past and assumed it was no good. Boy was I wrong. So, ok I haven't had their pizza or wings BUT I did order myself a focaccia sandwich with a cannoli! They make fresh focaccia daily.... say what?!?!? I LOVE foccacia. I had their chicken artichoke sandwich and I was simply in heaven. Awesome sandwich packed with meat, and packed with flavor and came with fries and pickles on the side. K, on to the cannoli. I was very skeptical. Especially after seeing it - rather on the narrow side if you

Kiley H.

Oct 11, 2016

Report

Standard pizza. Not bad, but not great either. We tried to pepperoni slice and stuffed slice and weren't super impressed, but it's decent and cheap!

Kim B.

Jul 23, 2016

Report

Stopped in for lunch today, unexpectedly, when the road through Downtown Webster was closed. The stop turned out to be a good one.

Since it was our first visit, we had to try one of their slices. Today's pick - pepperoni. The slice was fresh, the crust had a nice crunch to it, and the red sauce was tasty. Overall, a great slice. Will stop by again when wanting just a slice (or two).

Also tried an Italian assorted with mozzarella. Apparently they don't have fresh mozzarella since they put shredded mozzarella on the sandwich, that's my only complaint otherwise the sandwich was delicious

Jason S.

Mar 06, 2015

Report

Best New York style pizza in Webster! The service is outstanding for delivery. One thing to take notice of is their online coupons. I've found that they have the best prices for pizza deals in Webster.

Brandy Ortiz-Allen

Oct 03, 2014

Report

My fiance and I moved out to the Webster area from Buffalo in the beginning of the year (2014). We've tried a lot of pizza places around us, and this one is hands down our favorite. We really enjoy their food and their service. Everyone there is really nice and everything gets done really fast!