Isthmus Eye Care
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Isthmus Eye Care
Robyn is motivated to help our patients see better as well as mentor each member of the Isthmus Eye Care team. Her biggest interest is traveling and she is incredibly grateful to learn about other cultures. Abbey is passionate about Isthmus Eye Care and strives to provide the best patient experience.

In her spare time she enjoys spending time with her boyfriend, his two children and their Shiba Inu. She also enjoys reading, watching Wisconsin sports and exploring Madison. Amy's favorite aspect of working at Isthmus Eye Care is getting to know patients and their families. She likes to spend time with her husband Tristan, family and pet dog, Maggie.
Services
We have two convenient locations to serve you - in Middleton and east Madison. After booking your appointment, please review this important information below. We look forward to meeting you! We're glad to see you back! Once you have logged in to your Personal Health Record for Your Eyes, you can book a new visit from the home screen.
Dr. Colin Connors understands the importance of good eye health in achieving life goals. As a Middleton native and graduate of Middleton High School, Dr. Colin Connors moved to Chicago to study biology at DePaul University, and then graduated from the Illinois College of Optometry in 2009. Upon graduation Dr. Colin Connors was excited at the opportunity to get back home to Wisconsin.
Isthmus Eye Care is the eye clinic well-suited to take care of your vision and eye health needs. Please contact us to make an appointment or learn more about our services. As a service to our current patients, Isthmus Eye Care optometrists provide 24-hours-a-day, 7-days-a-week on-call service for eye emergencies.
Isthmus Eye Care is honored to be a part of the only global fundraising initiative that specifically targets the prevention of blindness and impaired vision due to refractive error. Optometry Giving Sight was established in 2003 to address the needs of the over 1 billion men, women and children around the world who are blind or visually impaired simply because they don't have access to an eye exam and appropriate glasses.
Isthmus Eye Care is a private eye care group with offices in Middleton and Madison. We are looking for a friendly and bright individual to join our team. Our clinics provide patients with eye health and vision care for the entire family - infants through seniors. The optometric technician/optician assists the doctor with managing patients as they go through various stages of their eye examination.
Reviews (20)
Scott Largent
Scott Largent
Dec 08, 2021
Report
Staff and Doctors are always so friendly and communicative in making the annual eye exam as comfortable as possible. They keep our health at the forefront of everything they do.
Kelly Antonson
Kelly Antonson
Oct 31, 2021
Report
My first visit to this office and I'll be back! From making the appointment, to the exam to the check out I had an incredibly pleasant experience. Everyone was friendly and kind and I've never laughed so much at an appointment! The doctor was very knowledgeable and shared options.
Cassandra Riggles
Cassandra Riggles
Sep 18, 2021
Report
Having been a patient at Isthmus Eye Care for at least seven years now, it's high time for a review. I now live out of state, but travelled back to WI recently and made a point to schedule my annual exam there. Over the years, Dr. Callie and her team of assistants have earned my complete trust with my eye health. I especially appreciate how Dr. Callie explains what she looks for in the retinal scans and shows me if or how they've changed over time. Robyn's ability to ask me a few questions about my eyewear preferences, then pick out a perfect pair are truly unparalleled. She's suggested the last
Sara Mc
Sara Mc
May 25, 2021
Report
Brooke made my experience choosing new frames so pleasant , thanks to professionalism, expertise, friendliness and a delightful sense of humor. I felt so at ease and confident that I would get some attractive and high quality frames and lenses; I ended up choosing something quite similar to what I had bought in the past in Texas --a bonus for me! I appreciated Brooke's honest feedback (which reinforced my confidence) about which frames and lens shape looked best on my face and would best meet my specific needs. The frame selection is more than sufficient. There were many beautiful choices. I brought
Bauj Vang
Bauj Vang
Sep 05, 2020
Report
By far the best experience I’ve ever had. I couldn’t stop talking about my positive experience to my husband when I got home. Everyone was very nice, knowledgeable, and attentive. Very welcoming environment with such a positive and friendly vibe. Everyone was so professional and just...happy! It made me want to work there too! Lol. Highly recommend! Dr. Callie M. was great! Can’t wait to be back in a year.
Emily M.
Emily M.
Aug 19, 2020
Report
I recently had an eye exam and purchased a new pair of glasses from Isthmus Eye Care. The whole experience went very well, the prices for frames and lenses are what I would describe as the higher side of reasonable.
Unfortunately, nobody called me to let me know my glasses were ready. I logged onto the patient portal on a whim this afternoon, and that's how I found out my order was ready for pickup. I double-checked all my contact information, spam folders, missed calls - there's no evidence on my end of an attempt to contact me. I understand that places get busy, but had I not checked I don't
Elizabeth Cameron
Elizabeth Cameron
Jun 15, 2020
Report
I'm not generally one to leave a review, but I had such an overwhelmingly positive experience that I had to share. Everyone in the office has a great attitude and explained everything to me from start to finish. The eye exam was such a simple and efficient process, from the COVID check-in requirements to the different eye tests. Leah was my tech, and she was such a ray of sunshine during my early morning appointment.
Dr. Jun is very intelligent and personable, and makes you feel right at home. He worked to understand my eye concerns and lifestyle and set me up with lenses that will work best for
Derek Schuld
Derek Schuld
Feb 07, 2020
Report
Justin was very cheery and chatty, which helped me ease into my initial consultation. I hadn't been to an optometrist in 25 years, so I was a little nervous. Dr. Kimrey was also very friendly and knowledgeable; she confidently answered the bevy of questions I had for her. I made the right choice in choosing Isthmus.
Lauren Brockman
Lauren Brockman
Jan 22, 2020
Report
I will never go anywhere else for glasses again. GREAT experience from start to finish. They looked up my insurance as soon as I walked in the door, then went over pricing for lenses, and lastly helped me pick out the perfect frames for my face! It was all seamless and efficient. Brooke was an amazing help in finding the perfect glasses. Highly highly highly recommend!! Go see them!
Stacy Isferding
Stacy Isferding
Jan 16, 2020
Report
I just went to Isthmus Eye Care yesterday for my first appointment. I have been seeing an eye doctor in my hometown my entire life, but I didn't want to keep driving back home for appointments. I saw them online and figured I would try them out. First, they got me in for an appointment the next day, which was nice. Dr. Wilson was very nice and thorough. He explained everything to me about my eye health and prescription and what options I had for contacts and eyeglasses. I appreciated all the eye exams/tests they conducted to make sure I was getting the best prescription for my new glasses. I was
Mary Ziegelbauer
Mary Ziegelbauer
Aug 05, 2019
Report
Highly recommend Isthmus Eye Care for the personalized service & care provided. Great customer service!
Java P.
Java P.
May 23, 2019
Report
Got my eyes checked by some of the nicest people I've met in a doctor's office in Wisconsin

Pros:
-location, in the same plaza as Metro Market on Cottage Grove
-beautiful modern office, lots of windows and chairs in the waiting area
-lots of frames to choose from
-everyone is all smiles from entry to exit
-complete eye exam included tests that I didn't have before at my previous eye doctor's office: color chart, extra focusing and optical muscles assessments, and general health checks like bp, hr, height, and weight.
-Dr. Wilson has a very pleasant chair-side manner, addressed
Mykl Thuong
Mykl Thuong
May 06, 2019
Report
This place is cool. Staff are knowledgeable, personable, and have a great sense of humor. You have to when I’m the patient. They have all the newest equipment and software (I know firsthand because I’m a… Software Analyst). And be sure you ask for Sara (Optometry Customer Engineering Specialist), she was very kind and caring. Dr. Kimrey is the top of her field. See her or be weary.
Loren H.
Loren H.
Mar 12, 2019
Report
Nice clean place with courteous efficient staff. Two year warranty on glasses was honored after cracks appeared in my lenses from the excessively cold weather this season. They do seem a little pricey compared to some others but you can shop around to be sure.
Veni V.
Veni V.
Mar 16, 2018
Report
Everyone here is super friendly. From the person who greets you to the doctors to everyone in between. Frames can get pricey but they are very helpful if you tell them a budget. I love that the person helping me find frames was so patient and fun to work with. This was my second visit and is definitely my eye place in Madison :)
Jamie Wacek
Jamie Wacek
Oct 11, 2017
Report
Had an eye emergency on a Saturday afternoon, called they got me in within a hour. Did an exam and put me to ease that everything was fine and scheduled a follow up appointment. Great service even on a Saturday and during a toranado warning!
Rebecca L.
Rebecca L.
Feb 13, 2014
Report
The opticians and optometrists at Isthmus Eye Care are so friendly and helpful. I recently had an eye exam and contact fitting here, and it was a great experience. Not a huge fan of having my pupils dilated, but they put some drops in afterward which was supposed to help the dilation go away faster. Dr. Maursetter was very nice and explained the purpose of all the tests she was running. It's always helpful when a professional is explaining what they are doing instead of just doing something and leaving you wondering why they are doing it. She gave me some daily contacts to try since I had
Alicia M.
Alicia M.
Aug 21, 2013
Report
Very thorough and pleasant staff. Dr Callie Maursetter was wonderful! Knowledgeable, professional and friendly. I've been going here for about 5 years and always have an pleasant experience. I will be a long time client!
Ashe D.
Ashe D.
Apr 04, 2012
Report
Quite possibly the best optometrist I have ever been to, and I have been seeing optometrists for almost 20 years.

Everyone here is SUPER nice. They make a point of cleaning all of the equipment you are going to be touching right in front of you. And (my favorite part) they don't do the puff test! They have this little contraption that touches your eye (I thought it would freak me out, but it was fine.) - WAY less stress than the damn puff test.

I will definitely be going here from now on for eye exams.
Kathleen S.
Kathleen S.
Mar 20, 2011
Report
Extremely competent staff. Got me into the right contact lenses on the first appt. Everyone was friendly and I interacted with every employee on my first visit. They have a Middleton clinic as well, and a good website with lots of information about the doctors. I researched a lot before I found them and I'm glad I made the right choice. Have already had friends go to see them.