As the Wayne, NJ's best Italian restaurant and pizzeria, our customers always come first, and it shows. We strive to offer you quality food in a pleasant atmosphere. All of our food is fresh and made to order from the best ingredients. We pride ourselves on the highest of standards, using only the freshest ingredients in each of our dishes.
Do you have an upcoming event or party? Events large and small, Neil's can do it all with our flexible catering packages and personalized menus. Step into a world of genuine, old-world flavor at Neil's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Wayne, New Jersey. Neil's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a BYOB establishment.
Do you have an upcoming event or party? Events large and small, Neil's can do it all with our flexible catering packages and personalized menus. Step into a world of genuine, old-world flavor at Neil's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Wayne, New Jersey. Neil's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a BYOB establishment.
Services
Welcome to Neil's Pizza - Wayne's number one choice for Italian cuisine! We pride ourselves on providing the highest levels of customer service, and we only use the absolute freshest, best quality ingredients for all of our dishes. From pasta to pizza to antipasti, Neil's has something for each and every palette.
Reviews (19)
Jehann D.
Jan 14, 2022
Report
This place is great. I'm not in the area often but a friend recommended this place and now it's my "go to" when I'm in the area. I went a while ago but still remember my first bite, the owner confidently said it was the best... he wasn't kidding!! I love their buffalo chicken pizza the service was fairly quick.. it's a hidden gem!!
Anthony I.
Dec 18, 2021
Report
Lousy food as the pizza is often undercooked, they go cheap on the quantity of food for sandwiches, the veal is made from roadkill, the people working there (quite a few) are obnoxious and they should just reform the place. Angelo's father in law Neal would not be happy with what his business turned into. Of course he still does his dirty because he gives freebies for the local Roman Catholic Church. This is what makes Wayne township look bad
Benjamin G.
Nov 26, 2021
Report
I needed to change the rating because it wasn't fair enough. This man working at Neil's made fun of me with his coworker because I calmly asked him for a second refill. I completely understand he cannot give me another one and he is doing his job. I am not disappointed by that at all. He felt the need to make fun of me with his coworker right in front of me. The employees at this restaurant need to be put in order because I may never step foot into this place ever again. I proudly present this place with one star.
Greg V.
Nov 02, 2021
Report
Linda J.
Oct 01, 2021
Report
Peter B.
Aug 01, 2021
Report
Aisha I.
Mar 21, 2021
Report
Pissed because there pizza is so good but there delivery guy is horrible,so he brings order,I'm paying with a card so I notice he already added a 30 percent tip so as I go to swipe my card I tap no tip on the device,he all of a suddens NO TIP NO TIP YOU THINK I WIORK FOR FREE STUPIDO
So I said excuse me i was giving you a tip in cash but now your not getting nothing, he turns around & says watch next time
SO BEFORE HE DIES SOMETHING TO MY FOOD,I WON'T CAN'T TRUST HIM
So I said excuse me i was giving you a tip in cash but now your not getting nothing, he turns around & says watch next time
SO BEFORE HE DIES SOMETHING TO MY FOOD,I WON'T CAN'T TRUST HIM
Mr. E.
Feb 11, 2021
Report
Brenda R.
Jan 24, 2021
Report
I was very excited about trying Neil's for the first time. A friend of mine mentioned that it had a more substantial crust, which is what I was looking for. I ordered a plain pie for pickup. My son had to drive 36 minutes to ouck it up. Unfortunately, when he got it home the bottom of the pie was burnt black. Such a waste of time and money.
L. J. K.
Dec 27, 2020
Report
Rania N.
Nov 21, 2020
Report
Kevin K.
May 06, 2020
Report
Liya M.
Jan 08, 2020
Report
Joey P.
Nov 14, 2019
Report
I've tried this pizza twice in the last month but wanted to check out the restaurant being it was local and sit down with a slice before I wrote this.
My first experience was my sister ordered from Neil's for a small family get together and I'm normally not blown away by many pizzas at this point because I know what I like as an Italian in NJ being here my whole life and eating pizza my whole life! But the sicilian was exceptionally good, I especially enjoyed the sausage on the pie which I'm pretty picky about. Cooked well, tasted great and not too fat like some sicilian slices
My first experience was my sister ordered from Neil's for a small family get together and I'm normally not blown away by many pizzas at this point because I know what I like as an Italian in NJ being here my whole life and eating pizza my whole life! But the sicilian was exceptionally good, I especially enjoyed the sausage on the pie which I'm pretty picky about. Cooked well, tasted great and not too fat like some sicilian slices
Nalini M.
Nov 11, 2019
Report
My favorite pizza place to stop by and eat when visiting Wayne. Their food is fresh and delicious. So many options for pizza, the toppings were endless. There is penne alla vodka, eggplant parmigiana, Chinese style chicken, veggie pizza etc. Their subs are also delicious and can be modify anyway. The sub was crispy and soft on the inside. It was wonderful. Very friendly workers. I basically ate here for 3 days straight for lunch. Do your self a favor and go check this place out.
Weihan Z.
Apr 11, 2019
Report
I've tried all the pizza places in the area and Neil's is hands down the best out of all. The crust is thin but not too thin and has great bite in it. It folds just as a pizza should fold, and the cheese and toppings don't just slide out. This is exactly what your classic Jersey-style pizzeria should be.
I've ordered pastas salads here a few times and their portions are all very large. If you're like me and you don't carry much cash, they don't bother you with some $10 credit card minimum. There's plenty of seating and the place is generally kept very clean
I've ordered pastas salads here a few times and their portions are all very large. If you're like me and you don't carry much cash, they don't bother you with some $10 credit card minimum. There's plenty of seating and the place is generally kept very clean
Desiree M.
Mar 17, 2019
Report
Since high school, this has been my favorite pizza place in Wayne. I love how they have so many different specialty pies. My favorite is the pesto chicken and buffalo chicken. In the past I have tried the spinach slice as well. Recently I had the chicken bacon ranch and it was a little dry/needed some more ranch and maybe they could've skipped over the fries. Anyway, when I am in the area I always try to stop here for a hearty slice.
Sara A.
Feb 02, 2019
Report
Vince M.
Jul 06, 2018
Report
I should start this brief review, with a qualification that I've only given it three stars because we've only gotten take out from Neil's.
All the items we've gotten have been absolutely wonderful! In particular, my order of mussels. They were plump, tender, and in a tomato sauce that was mostly tomato and very little oil. The bread that was supplied was fresh and crusty and absolutely perfect with an order of mussels.
Salads were generous, the wrap that we ordered was perfect, and the two orders of gnocchi could not have been better.
We look forward to going there again
All the items we've gotten have been absolutely wonderful! In particular, my order of mussels. They were plump, tender, and in a tomato sauce that was mostly tomato and very little oil. The bread that was supplied was fresh and crusty and absolutely perfect with an order of mussels.
Salads were generous, the wrap that we ordered was perfect, and the two orders of gnocchi could not have been better.
We look forward to going there again
