data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3a468/3a46868075b74737087d6ca8627daefc7ed399f8" alt="Nautilus Diner"
Stop by the Nautilus Diner of Massapequa and let us prepare a freshly made, delicious meal for you! Whether it's breakfast with friends or a fine dining experience, the Nautilus Diner will cater to your needs. Reserve our catering room for your next business event, shower, birthday or special party! Whether it's lunch, dinner, breakfast, snacks, or dessert, Nautilus Diner has what you are looking for. Our Massapequa diner has a beautiful bar and catering room for parties, celebrations, or lunch with friends.
Reviews (22)
Carol Lynch
Jan 14, 2022
Report
Colleen Mullins
Jan 09, 2022
Report
I ordered through Uber eats I order the hot open face turkey sandwich. I also paid for a priority delivery. So upon receipt the turkey and gravy were cold. I had to microwave to heat it up. Also I ordered peas as my side and received mixed veggie. I also ordered and paid for extra poultry gravy and never received it. This diner used to be a go to for me. But unfortunately I will never order from this diner again. I spent 32 dollars on a dinner that I wouldn’t feed to my dog. Super disappointed
Jamie Maloney
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Robin D.
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Jeffrey Waybright
Dec 18, 2021
Report
By far the customer service I've ever encountered. Ordered multiple dinners through grubhub for delivery, Yet when they arrived one of them was completely missing and replaced with something else. When we called the restaurant, they basically told me too bad, what we gave you cost costs more so we're not doing anything about it. Then tried blaming it on the language barrier of grubhub.
This is the 2nd time ordering delivery from this restaurant, the last time all of our entrees were missing vegetable and potato and we were asked "do you actually want it?"
Definitely not worth the price or aggravation
This is the 2nd time ordering delivery from this restaurant, the last time all of our entrees were missing vegetable and potato and we were asked "do you actually want it?"
Definitely not worth the price or aggravation
Tom K.
Nov 23, 2021
Report
Lets start off by saying I do like the food there. I went there enough that I knew the wait staff and certain waiters would want us in their section when we visited. What I dont like is when a manager is cheap. As we were walking out my son asked for a black and white cookie. I said no problem, we just paid a $100.00 bill plus a tip and for a dollar or two, no problem.
They charged the kid 5 bucks (and change) for a cookie. When I said something about it ,I get an excuse about how much icing is and payroll tax etc. Seriously? I can go to a bakery and get them for a buck or
They charged the kid 5 bucks (and change) for a cookie. When I said something about it ,I get an excuse about how much icing is and payroll tax etc. Seriously? I can go to a bakery and get them for a buck or
Desi Pilla
Nov 23, 2021
Report
The portions at Nautilus Diner are HUGE. You can bank on not needing to eat for the rest of the day after one of their pancake selections. Aside from the size, the taste was great (I recommend the nutella/banana pancakes!). The wait staff wasn't very organized and we had to wait quite a while for our food, but in the current hiring environment that may not be Natuilus's fault.
Linda Chapla
Oct 27, 2021
Report
Ilya Charny
Oct 22, 2021
Report
Melissa C.
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Laura Hunlock
Oct 10, 2021
Report
Bob S.
Oct 01, 2021
Report
I just ordered a tuna melt for lunch. The tuna was sour smelt little old wasn't that good. When I first ordered the waitress asked if I wanted fries and I said can I substitute fries she said yes you can get a salad. So I got a Greek salad. When I get the bill they charged me $9 for a side salad and $2 to change the cheese. The waitress should've said something when I ordered. When I told the manager, all he said was sorry about that.
Mei Ling
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Sharon Jackson
Sep 03, 2021
Report
I love coming here the food is always fresh and the presentation on point for a diner. The staffs uniforms are superb makes you feel like you're in a fancy restaurant. I had the soft shell crab franchise 😋 so good. I highly recommend it and they have a full bar 🍸for those that want a cocktail with dinner.
Rosaria C.
Aug 16, 2021
Report
I ordered through uber eats the other day and i'm just curious as to why a side of turkey bacon was $8.50? definitely was surprised when it showed up and it was only three slices for that much money. $8 for two sausage links? i could've gone to the grocery store and gotten 2 packs of turkey bacon and sausage for that much. there's 0 reason the food there should be that expensive. food is basic diner food go to a different diner up the street and get the exact same food for a reasonable price.
Donna V.
Jul 21, 2021
Report
Awful!!! Especially Paul, manager??? Did they recently change owners? He is horrible. I ordered food over the phone, they told me to come in 20 minutes, when I arrived they asked me to pay, waited and waited. Someone from the back finally came out and told me they never prepared the meal and was out of leg of lamb. Paul who said he was the manager did nothing. Not even an apology. Terrible!!
Scottie B.
May 23, 2021
Report
My family decided to finally dine indoors on this hot sunny day. We were warmly greeted by the friendly wait staff at the Nautilus Diner. We were impressed by how clean and safe the place was. The bathroom was immaculately clean and the tables were pristine. The food was absolutely delicious . I had the Santa Fe Wrap and my wife had the Chicken Souvlaki. The portion sizes were incredibly generous and the staff was very attentive. The iced coffee was delicious as well.
Karen N.
Dec 28, 2020
Report
So of my almost 70 years I have lived w'in 2 miles of this Massapequa/Amityville institution for over half a century While I was growing up my family ate here weekly, when I returned to LI in the late 80s my parents were still regulars and I often joined them. Never anything unusual other than Greek classics like a Gyro, Nautilus ALWAYS held the promise of good food prepared well for a reasonable price.
Since reopening we have given them a couple of chances to at least serve a 'worth the $$$ meal' and then, till this Thanksgiving, had given up!
As we all should know Thanksgiving
Since reopening we have given them a couple of chances to at least serve a 'worth the $$$ meal' and then, till this Thanksgiving, had given up!
As we all should know Thanksgiving
Mindy M.
Jun 28, 2020
Report
So, today's experience was a bit different. Food still good, different waiter and a seating for 4 with a table too small for all the individual plates. The waiter was not so smooth or quick as our previous experience.
I ordered waffles with strawberries and whip cream. Got waffles with fresh *rather tasty, cantaloupe and a touch of honeydew. Corrected the order- and was left standing there with a plate of beautiful strawberries and cream with no place to put it. I grabbed the child seat and placed things as the individual milk and butter pieces plate on it. I swapped out and condensed plates
I ordered waffles with strawberries and whip cream. Got waffles with fresh *rather tasty, cantaloupe and a touch of honeydew. Corrected the order- and was left standing there with a plate of beautiful strawberries and cream with no place to put it. I grabbed the child seat and placed things as the individual milk and butter pieces plate on it. I swapped out and condensed plates
Joe A.
Sep 08, 2019
Report
Tai Vicari
Oct 11, 2018
Report
Elmer the waiter was very nice and attentive. He's a keeper. The atmosphere is beautiful and I love the Art deco appeal. The food was MEH! I always order eggs at diners because if you can't master an egg dish you shouldn't be in the kitchen.
Perhaps they were busy or maybe eggs aren't their thing but my companion ordered Old Fashion French toast and it looked like it should have come with a shot of insulin. For the price you pay, add some garnish like a slice of orange or a fanned strawberry.
Perhaps they were busy or maybe eggs aren't their thing but my companion ordered Old Fashion French toast and it looked like it should have come with a shot of insulin. For the price you pay, add some garnish like a slice of orange or a fanned strawberry.
Donald J.
Jun 25, 2018
Report
I've been to this diner a few times and I don't know why I never wrote a review.
First of all the place is very spacious and clean and all of the people working there are courteous and helpful. They have a full bar that makes some very good cocktail.
The food is also very good but it all depends on what you order. I had the Manhattan clam chowder and stuffed clams for an appetizer both were cooked perfectly. The fish and chips were ok but the fish was a little Bland. Wifey had the crab cakes that she said was very good crunchy on the outside and flavorful and moist on the inside
First of all the place is very spacious and clean and all of the people working there are courteous and helpful. They have a full bar that makes some very good cocktail.
The food is also very good but it all depends on what you order. I had the Manhattan clam chowder and stuffed clams for an appetizer both were cooked perfectly. The fish and chips were ok but the fish was a little Bland. Wifey had the crab cakes that she said was very good crunchy on the outside and flavorful and moist on the inside