Harvest on Fort Pond is one of Montauk's top-rated restaurants. Established in 1994 it's been a local favorite for over 25 years. Executive Chef Jake Williams serves creative, sharable Montauk Italian inspired by local Montauk seafood and homegrown produce. The Harvest offers creative cocktails, amazing food, Seasonal garden dining and sunsets over Fort Pond.
1 Week in Advance Reservation Recommended for Indoor Dining - We accept ONLINE Reservations for parties up to 10 for indoor dining only, maintaining our 7 day in advance policy. Please use the RESERVATIONS Link.
1 Week in Advance Reservation Recommended for Indoor Dining - We accept ONLINE Reservations for parties up to 10 for indoor dining only, maintaining our 7 day in advance policy. Please use the RESERVATIONS Link.
Reviews (29)
Katie F.
Jan 18, 2022
Report
Visited MTK during the holiday MLK weekend and was so glad to see Harvest was open and could take us after our reservation fell through elsewhere. Calamari salad was the best part of the meal as well as the service we received from Kamoree (spelling). She was super sweet and made the dining experience feel homey and relaxed. Would definitely come back, best for groups given portion size and that everything is intended to be served family style.
Michael Kuhner
Jan 11, 2022
Report
We went there by the recommendation of my in-laws. We were there at night but I'm sure in the light of day the view is beautiful. We ate at the bar which holds about 8 to 10 people. Are bartender Ann was helpful attentive and very personable. We chose the porterhouse for two and the garlic fries. The steak was cooked perfect pre-sliced and as soft as butter. The fries were delicious. And made our drinks exactly the way we asked. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.
Karen M.
Jan 08, 2022
Report
Alexandra Rozhdestvenskaya
Dec 31, 2021
Report
Brenden Bishop
Dec 24, 2021
Report
TLDR; High end prices, okay food, poor service. Don’t recommend.
Went here for our 10th year anniversary, was really looking forward to it, and was incredibly disappointed. This restaurant just doesn’t make the cut for what it tries to be.
The food was just okay, service was poor. I went to give back my fork I used for a Buffalo mozzarella with balsamic vinaigrette and was told to keep it for my chicken parm. Not sure what “high end” or expensive Italian restaurant wants you to mix your balsamic fork with marina, but I assure you it’s not good. Not to mention, when they messed up our
Went here for our 10th year anniversary, was really looking forward to it, and was incredibly disappointed. This restaurant just doesn’t make the cut for what it tries to be.
The food was just okay, service was poor. I went to give back my fork I used for a Buffalo mozzarella with balsamic vinaigrette and was told to keep it for my chicken parm. Not sure what “high end” or expensive Italian restaurant wants you to mix your balsamic fork with marina, but I assure you it’s not good. Not to mention, when they messed up our
Brian C.
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Been here many times , seems like they are off there game the last 2 or 3 times. The staff all had looks on there face and a non friendly attitude, we are the easiest going patrons and the server wouldn't accommodate our guests who had gluten allergy , we just wanted a grilled piece of fish and vegetables and didn't care about price , they wouldn't go it for us. Very strange . From the hostess to the waiter and bar tender all had sour pusses on there faces . The restaurant was empty . We won't be back , plenty of other restaurants to eat at in Montauk for average food. Management
Scott R.
Nov 25, 2021
Report
K. H.
Nov 09, 2021
Report
I'm so glad i ignored the negative reviews on this place because everything this restaurant did was excellent.
Came to Montauk for my baby moon this past weekend and stupidly didn't make reservations anywhere. We walked in with the intention of sitting anywhere but when my husband told the hostess it was our last hoorah, she found us a table in less than 15 minutes.
The waitress was fantastic - super sweet and attentive despite her getting 5 tables sat right around the same time.
The food was great! We started with the clams and mussels - clams were great, mussels could have had
Came to Montauk for my baby moon this past weekend and stupidly didn't make reservations anywhere. We walked in with the intention of sitting anywhere but when my husband told the hostess it was our last hoorah, she found us a table in less than 15 minutes.
The waitress was fantastic - super sweet and attentive despite her getting 5 tables sat right around the same time.
The food was great! We started with the clams and mussels - clams were great, mussels could have had
T. Man
Nov 03, 2021
Report
Holy MACKEREL, This place is GREAT!!! We had a party of 6 and a 9pm seating. The staff was WONDERFUL and KIND. Did not rush us out the door. Explained it was family style and recommended not to over order. Food was AMAZING. Clean bathrooms, nice bar. Very fair prices. BEST place we ate at in 3 days at Montauk. HIGHLY Recommended.
Lj Crawford
Nov 01, 2021
Report
Lily C.
Oct 25, 2021
Report
I had the Veal Bolognese and it was quite delicious. Perfectly seasoned and the pasta was cooked the way I like it. I was surprised by the serving size which was intended to share. I am going to chalk it up to inflation.
My girlfriend had the chicken dish with mashed potatoes and it looked overcooked, puny and dry. She ate it didn't send it back but She didn't give it a glowing review. I'm so glad I ordered the pasta dish.
Great service, great food, great setting. Definitely one of the best restaurants in Montauk. It's great that they take reservations by Yelp! now. I still
My girlfriend had the chicken dish with mashed potatoes and it looked overcooked, puny and dry. She ate it didn't send it back but She didn't give it a glowing review. I'm so glad I ordered the pasta dish.
Great service, great food, great setting. Definitely one of the best restaurants in Montauk. It's great that they take reservations by Yelp! now. I still
Linda Tarpinian
Oct 19, 2021
Report
Barney Simon
Oct 12, 2021
Report
Brian H.
Oct 02, 2021
Report
You guys need to hire a new hostess because the service tonight was horrific. She told us it would be an hour wait and then when we were waiting at the entrance after an hour and a half, she then pushed us out of the door saying that she said two hours smirking saying "ok bye". It is a shame because this used to be our goto spot
Esta Jo
Sep 12, 2021
Report
Note: I rarely give anything 5 stars so consider my 4 stars very, very good. Dinner was lovely. We arrived early, the only available reservation was at 5, and we sat on a lovely porch. We were warned that the dishes were meant to share...thank goodness.
The margarita on ice was wonderful and got us into the mood for the following dinner. Pancetta Shrimp with Tuscan White Bean Salad was worth fighting over and we cleaned up with some crusty bread. The shrimp were grilled and the salad nicely spiced.
Then came Seafood Bruschetta. Shrimp, scallops, mussels, and clams in a spicy broth with toasted
The margarita on ice was wonderful and got us into the mood for the following dinner. Pancetta Shrimp with Tuscan White Bean Salad was worth fighting over and we cleaned up with some crusty bread. The shrimp were grilled and the salad nicely spiced.
Then came Seafood Bruschetta. Shrimp, scallops, mussels, and clams in a spicy broth with toasted
Christina C.
Sep 11, 2021
Report
Food was pretty good and so was the service in general. However, it was very odd when we asked the waitress for a wine recommendation, only to be told she doesn’t drink, so she had no idea. I’ve worked in restaurants with people who didn’t drink and they still had to know about taste profiles. Not exactly what you want to hear when you are spending 70 dollars on a bottle. But the ambiance is beautiful and it is worth a go.
Cyrus P.
Sep 06, 2021
Report
Come for the sunset, period.
Family style so don't eat with your eyes here.
Chicken fingers and fries for the 6 year old.
Ordered a pizza pie for two of us as an appetizer and some Pinot noir. For dinner we shared a linguine and clam dish and had more than half that lasted us thru lunch the next day. It's a good size for 3 large male adults to feel satisfied with.
Beautiful view. After dinner and dessert hit the dock for sunset photos. They're really beautiful.
Call for reservations. They also now take reservations online, apparently (a week in advance).
Family style so don't eat with your eyes here.
Chicken fingers and fries for the 6 year old.
Ordered a pizza pie for two of us as an appetizer and some Pinot noir. For dinner we shared a linguine and clam dish and had more than half that lasted us thru lunch the next day. It's a good size for 3 large male adults to feel satisfied with.
Beautiful view. After dinner and dessert hit the dock for sunset photos. They're really beautiful.
Call for reservations. They also now take reservations online, apparently (a week in advance).
Linda K.
Aug 24, 2021
Report
Upscale pricing, downscale vibe during our last visit. Swordfish was dry and the $48 rigatoni dish had very little meat. Service was rushed, crowded indoor dining area was warm and stuffy. Everyone (including servers) unmasked, hordes of kids running around yelling in the aisles unsupervised during COVID surge on LI. Didn't feel safe or valued as a customer.
Dawn L.
Aug 10, 2021
Report
A family favorite . Been coming For years summertime we order the same shareable meals every visit .
Salad , tomato pizza . Farfalle pasta , skirt steak , roasted chicken.
This 2021 visit , Sadly and Very surprised Did not make ANY small minimal accommodations for our GF celiac family member . Waiters run around like a workhorse And don't spend anytime at table for small talk .
Salad , tomato pizza . Farfalle pasta , skirt steak , roasted chicken.
This 2021 visit , Sadly and Very surprised Did not make ANY small minimal accommodations for our GF celiac family member . Waiters run around like a workhorse And don't spend anytime at table for small talk .
Nicole R.
Jul 24, 2021
Report
Really hard to get a reservation here (basically impossible) but if you show up right when they open... you can get seated outside within like two hours. The cocktails are pricey but good - I highly suggest the lavender martini. Their bread is out of this world. It makes no sense but they give you shredded Parmesan cheese and olive oil and you mash it together with the bread and it's an amazing mess. The calamari salad is a strong starter, and for mains I would suggest the chicken parm, the penne pasta and the side of garlic fries. Everything is sooooo yummy here! While it sucks that it&apos
HungryMan T.
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Julia M.
Jun 12, 2021
Report
Christine D.
Jun 11, 2021
Report
Mell M.
Jun 10, 2021
Report
A group of my friends and I called last minute to see if we could make a reservation; they we super accommodating and fit us in despite being busy. Parking wasn't an issue as the lot was big. Staff was friendly. And, most importantly, the food was amazing. When looking at the menu we were taken aback by the costs of the entrees, but once we received our food it made perfect sense. This restaurant is "family styled" (aka they give you large servings and everyone shares). The food was delicious (the seafood bruschetta was TO DIE FOR; scallops were fresh and soft like mozzarella). Other
Travis S.
Jun 07, 2021
Report
Came in for our uncountable time and it's still one of our favorite restaurants! We were seated by Hailey who made sure we had a great table for our anniversary. Our waitress was Tommysha and she was absolutely amazing. She made sure everything was perfect in a timely manner. Her personality was humble and fun. The food is always incredible! Stop in for a wonderful view and a great meal!
Jerry C.
May 23, 2021
Report
Food was excellent. Linguine with clams and veal bolognese best we ever had. Reservations max 1 week in advance. Phones open at 3pm on Saturday for next Saturday and they are filled right away. We arrived at 4:30 for first come to sit at the bar. We were first :) and by 5 pm when doors opened there were 15 groups waiting behind us and this was a week before Memorial Day. This is the best place and hardest to get in place in Montauk but oh so worth it.
Michelle S.
Apr 22, 2021
Report
Omg! Wish we knew about this restaurant sooner! Their seafood bruschetta is literally the best meal I've had in the Hamptons! It is not only affordable and HUGE, but they give huge portions! DONT forget to ask for extra bread because it is drenched in delicious sauce!
We ordered to go but my husband said the restaurant and views were beautiful.
We ordered to go but my husband said the restaurant and views were beautiful.
Erick S.
Feb 02, 2021
Report
Van V.
Aug 18, 2020
Report
What a lovely spot and fantastic food.
It was a birthday celebration for us. Since we were a large group, we did take out to have on our deck. But the patio dining there looked gorgeous.
Our order was on time. The clams, mussels, and scallops in that bruschetta sauce...wow. Calamari with frisée salad...wow. Grilled oysters...amen. Great breads and flatbreads. Chicken parm sauce was too sweet. Three pastas...all amazing. Loved the bow ties with sausage and peas and the tubes with bolognese.
We enjoyed doing the big share of small tastes. A great festive birthday meal.
It was a birthday celebration for us. Since we were a large group, we did take out to have on our deck. But the patio dining there looked gorgeous.
Our order was on time. The clams, mussels, and scallops in that bruschetta sauce...wow. Calamari with frisée salad...wow. Grilled oysters...amen. Great breads and flatbreads. Chicken parm sauce was too sweet. Three pastas...all amazing. Loved the bow ties with sausage and peas and the tubes with bolognese.
We enjoyed doing the big share of small tastes. A great festive birthday meal.
