Jerry's Pizza Pie

Jerry’s pizza pie is absolutely amazing. Claudio is a great owner, down to earth, and makes really quality pizza. The buffalo pizza is to die for. I go here on a weekly basis, all the staff is very friendly.

Jerry's Pizza Pie has been my go since we moved to Honey Brook when I'm craving for some crispy chicken salad , fried Zucchini, wrap or pasta dish . Portions are generous and certainly satisfying..

I’ve found Jerry’s pizza pie to be the most delightful establishment I’ve been to in years. Not only is the food hands down amazing! But the workers and atmosphere is as well!

Have been to Jerry's before. Every time I've been here it has been a good experience. The waitress was nice and attentive and the food was adequate. My only complaint is because I used a card, $.43 was added to my bill. I may have missed it, but this should be somewhere on the menu that using a card will incur a fee.

3 stars. Sans fee, 4 stars.

Best pizza place in Honey Brook! Food is delicious!! Stromboli's,calzones and spaghetti are very good. Atmosphere is very nice. Servers are great polite and courteous . Prices are good. Highly recommend eating there.

Placed an order for pick up, they repeated the order back to us. When we picked up they stated the order as they rang it up & 1 item was left off, when it was brought to their attention it was clear that they had forgotten it, we waited for the item to get done. We didn't check the rest of the order..our fault!! Once home we found that half the order wasn't in the bag 😡 AND the item they had to make because they forgot was obviously thrown together & had absolutely NO flavor! It was terrible!!!

I grew up with Jerry's Pizza Pie. Can't say I've ever had a bad experience in 30+ years. One of the few places that makes Chicken Marsala correctly.

Its a regular lunch stop for my MC club when we are in the area. Last time we went, they saw us through the window and immediately started setting up a large table for us. Definitely made us feel welcome.
The food is very good, large portions and good pricing.

Great place and the food is good. They always listen if there's something in the dish that you don't like they'll do there best to cater what you want. They are very accommodating especially when it gets close to closing time and they never say the grill or fryer is done for the night. Always friendly when you call.

Good people and can tell they wanna make good food, and when you ask for extra cheese they friggin give u extra cheese. Downside is their pizza sauce taste like nothing, I would recommend and go here more often but I love marinara and if they worked on it a bit, maybe it was this specific batch that wasn't good not sure.

Great delicious food great service. Employees are great they greet you promptly they're friendly and respectful. All while working at the speed of light racing through the kitchen, phones ringing off the wall, the waitresses. Put out an extreme amount of food at such a feverish pace and still best quality. Thanks pizza pie. Great food great service

I have not been to Jerry's in a while just because of where I live but I got to say the pizza is great and pleasant people working the counter
Looks like I will have to go out of the way to go to Jerry's more often

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Staff is always polite and friendly. Orders are handled quickly and they have a great drink selection. Love this place I always stop when I pass through.

If you want a lot of extras with cheese melted on top, The Special Cheesesteak is the cheesesteak for you. We did have a roll blow out.

Tremendous pizza, salad and calzone. Friendly staff. Great beer selection. Support you local businesses and tip well!

I love the pizza here! The sauce is sweet and tastes so good! Always have my order correct and ready to go when I arrive!

Since the Covid 19 every Saturday we decided to support our local pizza shops. So for 2 months we have ordered pizza from all the pizza shops in the area. We must say out of all the places we ordered from Jerry's had the best pizza. Also the staff were the most appreciative for our business. We ordered Chicken Parmesan dinners this Sunday which was very good, was a very big portion. We highly recommend Jerry's

It's our favorite place to go eat here in Honeybrook. Tried all the other pizza places but their pizza crust and service was the best. Spent 2 years going through their menu... never a bad dish. Just moved again and we'll be missing them almost as much as the grandchildren!

Always good food and friendly service. I go there at least twice a week I've got to be friends with most of the staff. I really have no need to place my order, they always know what I want.

Ten years ago when we had family living in the area we frequented Jerry's Pizza Pie. Their pizza and pepperoni rolls are awesome. We fell in love with their cheesesteak pizza. Well, five years ago we had no more family nearby and we did not get t the area. Well, today we stopped and brought home three large cheesesteak pizzas and 48 pepperoni rolls - enough to save for our Super Bowl party. So glad we went the extra way for this. Great food and wonderful people. You have to stop in here and enjoy for yourself.

They have redeem them self from a few years ago . They have great white pizza and there margarita pizza is the best I ever had . It's a must eat in for that pizza tho as its crust will get soft in the box on the way home .

This place is okay, but they screw up a lot!! Ordered a sicilian pizza, they made a round pizza. Gave us a bottle of soda to make up for it? Should've made another one instead of that lame offer, specially since we are return customers. My daughter ordered wings, she got something that was not wings and it was fire engine hot. There have been other mistakes as well. Make them read the order back to you, and check it all before you leave, and make them make it right, right there and then.
*You can get the 40 oz cans they sell for half the price everywhere else, highway robbery prices there

Awesome food!
I always order the Veal Parmigiana sandwich with the roll on the side.
I eat half and take half home.
Ask for Rosa for your waitress, she is totally awesome!
The pizza is great too.
The wife loves their seafood special.
......."......................"................".............l..........".........

My wife and I just moved to Honey Brook and wanted some pizza. We were very pleased with the food here. We got sliced of the bbq and cheesesteak pizza. We will be going back in the future for sure!

This is really good pizza if you are in the Morgantown/Honeybrook area. It is surprising because the place is kind of attached to a gas station. When you go in, it's really nice. They also sell eclectic six packs of beer. They are friendly and it is a nice place too.