Five Star Collision Center
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
We understand that many times it is a frustrating experience that brings you across our path. Mostly, we meet by "accident." It is important that your experience with us exceeds your expectations. Our skilled and certified staff will prepare an accurate estimate. You will receive high quality work in a timely manner to get you back on the road safely and looking good.

Our 10,000 square foot facility is centrally located behind the Hamilton County Fairgrounds in the heart of Carthage. We are qualified to repair all makes and models of vehicles. We understand not all accidents turn into claims. If you are in this situation, stop by for an estimate of damage and we will make arrangements to work with you on the repair.
Services
A limited lifetime warranty is offered on the repaired claim for as long as you own the vehicle. Five Star Collision Center, Inc. has been inspected and approved by the Underwriters Laboratories and has been awarded the Good Housekeeping Seal. We are also certified and licensed by the Ohio Collision Board of Motor Vehicles.
As the owner of a motor vehicle damaged in an accident, by law you have the right to choose the repair shop of your choice. No. Do not waste your time shopping for estimates. Select a repair facility, then notify your insurance company, or ask the shop to make the call on your behalf. Most policies require notification.
We as a family have been able to bring any type of auto issues to Five Star Collision with GREAT results. Having 2 children and many cars. They have been able to provide any service needed. The service is quick and done right. We have had several all over paint jobs with special graphics. All of which turned out very nicely and were a BIG hit.
Reviews (9)
Robert A.
Robert A.
Sep 23, 2021
Report
They did some touch ups on my almost new car and it was perfect!
Quick and reasonable!
I'll go back.
Kelly Mullen
Kelly Mullen
May 22, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality
I highly recommend this collision center. Their service was outstanding. They worked with my insurance company to handle all the details. They had my car back to me in only a few days. I was very pleased with the overall job.
Services: Body & Trim, Painting, General repairs & maintenance
Eric Guyer
Eric Guyer
Jun 19, 2020
Report
My mother-in-law required collision repair for her Lexus. Our first quote was from a shop recommended by the dealer. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the estimate seemed high, so we Googled for something local and independent. Based on reviews, I stopped by to meet with Paul and Lisa. So thankful we did! They were courteous, Covid-conscious, and instantly trustworthy. The estimate was reasonable so we scheduled the drop-off/pickup with them offering to take her home. The quality of work is excellent and we highly recommend Five Star Collision. Definitely worth five stars and more than living up to the name
Margee Moore
Margee Moore
Oct 03, 2019
Report
Super helpful staff showed us the part they had to replace. Very trustworthy. Nice clean office where you pay. Highly recommend this hidden gem.
Theresa Amwake
Theresa Amwake
Dec 10, 2018
Report
Had a great experience working with Five Star! Excellent work and reasonably priced. They treat your car as if it's their own. Paul did a wonderful paint job on my husbands older Mustang. I would highly recommend them for collision repair, painting and detailing!
RonAnna Bisher
RonAnna Bisher
Oct 06, 2018
Report
We had great service from Five Star Collision.
In our industry, it is necessary to look professional when meeting clients. We used their services to detail our cars. They came back looking fabulous! I would highly recommend this business!
Tmp
Tmp
Aug 07, 2018
Report
In my industry, we experience dents and dings with our new drivers buy beyond that, we have had several situations where someone has hit us. When a drivers training car has toniff the road for Repair, we can potentially lose money.
Not with 5-Star Collision Center ! They get our cars back to us in great time, great condition and make it so convenient with a pick up and delivery service! Their name reflects their work!
Team LogicIt
Team LogicIt
Jul 28, 2018
Report
Five Star repaired my wife’s MDX back to a show a room finish after a fender bender. Have been very pleased with how they detailed my Cadillac Escalade. I took one of my company cars to have the wrap removed. They do great work and are very reasonable. I highly recommend Five Star!
Kevrep
Kevrep
Jun 23, 2018
Report
I've known Lisa Russell for years. She's honest and cares about her customers. I trust Five Star to always do a great job.