Enjoy the best of Cape May with a stay at Blue Fish Inn. Our Cape May hotel is open year-round and is conveniently located in the heart of town just minutes from the white sandy beaches and the Cape May pedestrian mall. Family owned and operated, our 1950s-style motel received a facelift to better accommodate our guests.
Formerly the "Madison Motel", the Blue Fish Inn offers comfortable, immaculate and affordable rooms. We have equipped the facility with numerous modern amenities in order to ensure your stay is enjoyable. The Blue Fish Inn offers 12 ground-level units. In the off-season the Blue Fish Inn caters to birding & fishing enthusiasts and quiet romantic getaways.
Formerly the "Madison Motel", the Blue Fish Inn offers comfortable, immaculate and affordable rooms. We have equipped the facility with numerous modern amenities in order to ensure your stay is enjoyable. The Blue Fish Inn offers 12 ground-level units. In the off-season the Blue Fish Inn caters to birding & fishing enthusiasts and quiet romantic getaways.
Services
Along with his business partner, Lena Miller, and the wonderful staff we make it our passion to provide caring hospitality to ALL who work hard throughout the year and desire a vacation filled with long lasting memories.
We pride ourselves in providing you with the highest quality service at a cost that still allows you and your loved ones to participate and enjoy the numerous activities and the great establishments in the historic City of Cape May New Jersey.At our Cape May hotel, we provide our guests with the same experience that we desire when on vacation, from the time a room is reserved to check-out.
We pride ourselves in providing you with the highest quality service at a cost that still allows you and your loved ones to participate and enjoy the numerous activities and the great establishments in the historic City of Cape May New Jersey.At our Cape May hotel, we provide our guests with the same experience that we desire when on vacation, from the time a room is reserved to check-out.
When looking for affordable Cape May motels, look no further than the Blue Fish Inn. From our standard-sized rooms to suites with a full kitchen, we offer a variety of accommodations, perfect for small or larger families. Enjoy convenient in-room amenities with clean, modern details and furnishings.
When searching for Cape May boutique hotels, look no further than the Blue Fish Inn, where our complimentary services are second to none! We provide our guests with the same amenities that we desire when on vacation! Clean accommodations, fresh towels and bed linens, comfortable beds for a well-rested night's sleep.
Can I leave my dog in the room? Yes, you may leave your dog(s) in the room unattended. We prefer that they are crated, but it is not required. To reserve a room with your pet you MUST provide a working, active cell phone number that you will carry with you throughout your stay. If your pet is barking excessively or seems to be experiencing some distress, we will contact you at the provided number and ask you to return to check on their safety.
On-site parking is available for 1 car per room (small to mid-size vehicles). Larger and additional vehicles may park on the street where there's plenty of space and NO METERS. Our outdoor, heated pool is open from Memorial Day Weekend and closes at the end of Columbus Day Weekend. Daily hours are from 10am-7pm.
Reviews (17)
David C.
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Terry S.
Jun 03, 2021
Report
Having never been to Cape May, chose this location based on reviews+price which seemed to equal value. Advance impression was excellent - I called several times with questions and Lena was always personable, knowledgeable and patient. The tri-fecta of customer service! Pulling up in front was happy to see pictures matched actual (as we all have sadly learned, not always the case), check-in was a breeze (again with Lena) and enjoyed a humorous back and forth with Franco. Into the room and - no major disappointments. Perhaps slightly smaller than I expected, but super clean, nicely appointed,
C. & Apos S. M.
Feb 20, 2021
Report
We loved this place! Franco was so personable and helpful on the phone . We stayed in the pet friendly room with our two puppies and It has a kitchenette , stocked with dishes, cookware.
Dish network so there is lots that watch on the TV.
Clean, cozy comfy beds.
We were here in the off season but still this location is perfect to go everywhere!
Dish network so there is lots that watch on the TV.
Clean, cozy comfy beds.
We were here in the off season but still this location is perfect to go everywhere!
Kris S.
Aug 31, 2020
Report
Great little place out of the way of the hustle and bustle. Extremely clean! As a matter of fact, cleaner than most other places I've ever stayed, especially chain hotels. Lena and Franco were extremely warm and friendly! And the cleaning staff top notch. Close enough to walk down Washington Street to the mall, or to see some of the beautiful homes in the area, even a walk to the beach is not far. We also loved that you are to not be loud after 10:00 p.m. The only downfall....people that think they need to be up at the crack of dawn, carrying on, laughing and hooping it up on the porch
Kim M.
Nov 16, 2019
Report
What a hidden gem. This motel is conveniently located within walking distance to what locals refer to as "the mall". The rooms are updated with the necessities like microwaves and small refrigerators and cable TV. Some even have kitchens. We weren't in town long enough to worry about cooking so we had the two queen beds which is somewhat larger of a room than the ones equipped with a kitchen. We were in Cape May for coast guard graduation and this Inn worked out great because we all stayed here. It's very clean with daily service. Another note, they have a few pet-friendly
Lon G.
Jun 10, 2019
Report
Stefanie F.
May 23, 2019
Report
Breanna G.
Apr 24, 2019
Report
I stayed for a Coast Guard graduation and this was the perfect place for me; I only needed a one night stay & it was just for me. Check in & check out was fast and easy. My room (room 5 I believe) was nice and clean when I came in. I was also able to check in at 11 since my plane landed so early. The heater worked great but it was a little loud. And in the morning, sunlight came in providing great light for my makeup (-: Bathroom is a little small, & the shower has shampoo/conditioner/body wash dispenser inside. Plenty of towels were provided & there was a mirror on the door. If
Trish S.
Aug 07, 2018
Report
Martha M.
Jun 18, 2018
Report
Rose G.
Jul 24, 2017
Report
Clara F.
Apr 06, 2017
Report
Michael B.
Jul 12, 2016
Report
My girlfriend and I were looking for a place that accepted pets so that we could get away for a nice weekend. We found it. The place was clean and they really pay attention to detail. The landscaping was beautiful and they even had a pool. Only 6 blocks from the beach. Fast Wi-Fi. The owners were amazing! So friendly and accommodating! We would definitely stay again.
Jaclyn C.
Apr 13, 2015
Report
I just returned yesterday from a Friday to Sunday stay at The Blue Fish Inn and I was very impressed. It was a very clean and cute room. It had everything I needed, in fact things I brought from home like coffee or pillows, I didn't even need to pack because they supplied so much and then some. My dog was also along for the trip and she enjoyed it too! Not only was the area dog friendly but there was a big park right around the corner. The hotel is so close to the beach as well as the shops and restaurants in the area. If I got in my car, I never had to drive more than five minutes away! Also
Kaitlyn B.
Jul 29, 2013
Report
Amanda L.
Oct 23, 2011
Report
"The "Stardust of Cape May""
A cheap hotel that's like a time-warp; a ride that leaves you feeling like you haven't showered in three days. I mean this in a good way, I think. Like the Vegas Stardust!
My buddy and I had two room NON-DOG suite that boasted: two full beds, a separate Queen bedded room, a mini-fridge, a microwave and two tiny yet surprisingly decent flat-screen televisions. Each room also had a window, an air conditioner, a dresser and a mirror that made sure you saw all the angles of awesome that each room possessed.
Plus side: CHEAP. Good wi-fi
A cheap hotel that's like a time-warp; a ride that leaves you feeling like you haven't showered in three days. I mean this in a good way, I think. Like the Vegas Stardust!
My buddy and I had two room NON-DOG suite that boasted: two full beds, a separate Queen bedded room, a mini-fridge, a microwave and two tiny yet surprisingly decent flat-screen televisions. Each room also had a window, an air conditioner, a dresser and a mirror that made sure you saw all the angles of awesome that each room possessed.
Plus side: CHEAP. Good wi-fi
Christopher M.
Sep 13, 2009
Report
Nice little dog-friendly motel I found on the interwebs. took Cara & Rocco there for two nights after the holiday weekend ended. very nice, clean, pleasant staff. parking lot was a little cramped and hard to maneuver around in. nice little park only a block away, quicky drive, boke or walk to the "downtown" Cape May area or beach. off season rates were reasonable, and they charged an extra $25 per night for the dog. had a little kitchen area with 4 small electric burner range (only two worked I think), we made pasta the first night and went out to eat the following.
