Hatch and Anthony Serpico opened in the Jersey shores in 1994 and continues here on Maui with the same authentic Italian cuisine! Serpico's history in Italian recipes go back to Italy and continues on with the traditions of a real "Pizzeria". Our Maui location is in tune with having the same theme and feel of our Pizzeria in New Jersey.
Our traditional homemade Italian recipes have been in our family for generations! It is a known fact that pizza varies widely in style from region to region, and it's clear that the thin, hand tossed pizza served at Serpico's is some of the most authentic Jersey-style pizza on island. See, the proprietor hails from New Jersey (insert your own Jersey accent here) and has 30+ years of experience in the pizza-making profession.
Our traditional homemade Italian recipes have been in our family for generations! It is a known fact that pizza varies widely in style from region to region, and it's clear that the thin, hand tossed pizza served at Serpico's is some of the most authentic Jersey-style pizza on island. See, the proprietor hails from New Jersey (insert your own Jersey accent here) and has 30+ years of experience in the pizza-making profession.
Reviews (26)
Tj S.
Jan 23, 2022
Report
Shani H.
Jan 20, 2022
Report
Came here one night while looking for a late meal in Pukalani. Its one of the few places open past 9pm. I ordered a slice of pizza with kalua pork and a side salad. A bonus was the breadsticks that came to the table for free. Everything was super tasty. The pizza slice was large and filling and the breadsticks were amazing. I had to control myself on the bread. I would definitely go back. I see they serve wine but I didnt partake. However, I could see myself going back for a sip.
Kristin M.
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Called in and placed a pickup order the other night. When I showed up the restaurant was super busy and I had to wait a little longer than expected. This to me is awesome because that means my food comes out hot so I never mind waiting!
We ordered the shrimp scampi, penne a la vodka, meatball sub, and a slice of pizza. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were huge as always so we had leftovers in the fridge for lunch the next day. This place is consistently awesome. Thank you guys for your hard work!
We ordered the shrimp scampi, penne a la vodka, meatball sub, and a slice of pizza. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were huge as always so we had leftovers in the fridge for lunch the next day. This place is consistently awesome. Thank you guys for your hard work!
Brian S.
Dec 13, 2021
Report
Serpico's This straightforward neighborhood pizza restaurant renovated the dining area before Covid newvtables they added a liquor license including a cocktail menu but frankly although I still like the place I didn't feel it was an improvement,
What last night the Real Serpico's reemerged's local pizza restaurant with friendly service Good food the tables have been spread out a little bit for Covid which made them comfortable they were busy the pizza cook was knocking out the orders as quickly as she could throw the pizzas. The two servers that waited on us were friendly
What last night the Real Serpico's reemerged's local pizza restaurant with friendly service Good food the tables have been spread out a little bit for Covid which made them comfortable they were busy the pizza cook was knocking out the orders as quickly as she could throw the pizzas. The two servers that waited on us were friendly
Frank S.
Dec 12, 2021
Report
We are local have been coming for years, the last three times the food has been horrible, dried out sandwiches and dried out pizza with no red sauce.
They need to hire a professional cook because this guy is a joke looks like he's high all the time. Sorry to say we won't be back! Not worth the drive from kihei anymore!
Want some advise hire a real professional cook! Good luck have not been to prison pizza in a while I hope it's not bad too.
They need to hire a professional cook because this guy is a joke looks like he's high all the time. Sorry to say we won't be back! Not worth the drive from kihei anymore!
Want some advise hire a real professional cook! Good luck have not been to prison pizza in a while I hope it's not bad too.
Bobby Dean
Dec 11, 2021
Report
I love this place and went all the time when I lived in Makawao. my girlfiend is flying into NYC to join me for my birthday next week and when she asked me where I wanted to have my birthday dinner I replied. Serpico's!!! Miss you guys, I'll get there again soon. remember when I used to take the pie home on my tanks? HAPPY NEW YEAR!!
Amanda N.
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Cindy S.
Nov 28, 2021
Report
Ulle
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Lianna Martin
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Lynn Keith
Sep 29, 2021
Report
Karla W.
Sep 16, 2021
Report
Leslee O'Neal
Aug 26, 2021
Report
Victor Hernandez
Aug 13, 2021
Report
Kelly F.
Jul 27, 2021
Report
Steve Mohr
Jul 16, 2021
Report
After a change in elevation of over 8,000+ feet, a stop here after long hikes in the Haleakala Park and sticking around to see the sunset was a delightfully unexpected surprise since some of the other local restaurants close early. Friendly staff and tasty pizza, burgers and beverage options of all ages makes this location a must visit. A five ⭐️ would only be achieved if the location was updated.
Cristabella C.
Jun 20, 2021
Report
First off they're forcing a gratuity of 20/30% but don't allow seating within business hours even when they have open seating . But we Can eat OUTSIDE - the food is mediocre at best.
The lady that turned us away was named Cara. It's Saturday night. I get you want to go home but - the restaurant is overcharging for Pasta overcharging and forcing an insane gratuity and you're turning away paying guests.
That's just poor customer service if you ask me
Go to casa nova
The lady that turned us away was named Cara. It's Saturday night. I get you want to go home but - the restaurant is overcharging for Pasta overcharging and forcing an insane gratuity and you're turning away paying guests.
That's just poor customer service if you ask me
Go to casa nova
Janeatte
Jun 18, 2021
Report
Gabriel C.
Jun 05, 2021
Report
I don't write reviews... I just don't. I use Yelp whenever my wife and I are in a new place, and trying to figure out what's good in the area. But I always forget to write a review, or the service / food was too mediocre to bother writing about it.
So when I tell you Serpico's pizza is the BEST Pizza in all of Maui, so much so that it propelled me to write my first review in YEARS, you know I believe this to be true.
Waitress was great / attentive, and the pizza chef (son of the owner) was really friendly.
Now, down to the pizza biz.
I got a pepperoni, pineapple, &
So when I tell you Serpico's pizza is the BEST Pizza in all of Maui, so much so that it propelled me to write my first review in YEARS, you know I believe this to be true.
Waitress was great / attentive, and the pizza chef (son of the owner) was really friendly.
Now, down to the pizza biz.
I got a pepperoni, pineapple, &
Gina P.
May 25, 2021
Report
Alicia W.
Apr 24, 2021
Report
Lei H.
Nov 30, 2020
Report
Andrea G.
Sep 19, 2020
Report
We live in Pukalani and do not have much delivery up here. We finally tried Serpico's for delivery and we are not disappointed. The food was still hot (too hot to eat...preferred) and so Ono! We ordered calamari, Caesar salad, spaghetti and meatballs, pasta primavera (came with focaccia and a side Caesar salad) and a cheeseburger with French fries. The delivery person was so polite too! All was perfect! We will definitely order again!!!
Holly B.
Dec 02, 2019
Report
We were warmly welcomed as soon as we walked into the restaurant.
We promptly ordered a pizza to go and waited while it was baked, about 20 minutes. Told it was better than Boston Pizza on Oahu, we were willing to try it.
We ordered a small Serpico's Special, substituting black olives for green peppers. The pizza was flat crusted, which I prefer, and piping hot. It was good. I'd like to return to try some of the pastas and salads on the menu.
We promptly ordered a pizza to go and waited while it was baked, about 20 minutes. Told it was better than Boston Pizza on Oahu, we were willing to try it.
We ordered a small Serpico's Special, substituting black olives for green peppers. The pizza was flat crusted, which I prefer, and piping hot. It was good. I'd like to return to try some of the pastas and salads on the menu.
Roger Green
Oct 09, 2019
Report
The is small quaint Italian restaurant earns a rare 5 stars from me for the fantastic tasting food, the extremely large portion size, and very reasonable prices. Portion size is goog for at least one more leftover meal. What this place lacks for atmosphere is made up by the fantastic tasting food and great service. The restaurant is small and quaint. The other dishes we saw other customers order looked just as good or better than the entrees we ordered. We can't wait to come back here the next time we are on Maui. Photos of our entree dishes attached to this review and labeled. Don't miss this
Maria P.
Apr 05, 2019
Report
After a day of zip lining, we were ready for some grub. Not too many options upcountry on a Sunday afternoon, but luckily I remembered Serpico's and they happened to be open. I've lived on Maui most of my life, but this was the first time actually stepping foot in here.
This is a quaint family-owned little restaurant located in the town of Pukalani. They offer a mix of pastas, sub sandwiches, & of course pizza! Jersey style pizza to be exact - thin, hand made, and hand tossed in front of your eyes and baked till the cheese is golden brown.
The bar area is the best spot to see
This is a quaint family-owned little restaurant located in the town of Pukalani. They offer a mix of pastas, sub sandwiches, & of course pizza! Jersey style pizza to be exact - thin, hand made, and hand tossed in front of your eyes and baked till the cheese is golden brown.
The bar area is the best spot to see
