Black Sheep Bagel Cafe
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
PLEASE NOTE: We are not able to accommodate bulk orders of bagels As-Is without advance notice of one week, as we have a very small kitchen with limited daily baking capacity. A bulk order is considered more than 4 bagels. Please note: All orders require a minimum of one week's notice, and are not guaranteed until you receive confirmation.

We are currently unable to accommodate any weekend catering or bulk orders, as we are baking at our maximum capacity for Saturdays and Sundays. Thank you for understanding! The market is an outpost of our cafe. We bring over fresh bagels every day, and sell them alongside all the spreads and toppings you need to make your own Black Sheep Bagel sandwich.
Reviews (9)
Gabriel Cristea
Gabriel Cristea
Jan 24, 2022
Report
Their cozy ambiance of the place is what I like the most. Welcoming, warm and laid back style is most appropriate.
Bagels: consistently good, a little chewy, with an classic and modern array of flavors and recipes.
Excellent selection of coffee and teas.
Would encourage the owners to enhance their bagel recipe, a little bit plain, could be more flavorful.
Also, they need a better system of service. Walked in on a Monday morning, just one client ahead of me but still had to wait 5 minutes plus to get my plain bagel while they had 4 people behind the counter. Nevertheless, the staff is cool and
Heart & Fern Photography Braeden Brkich
Heart & Fern Photography Braeden Brkich
Jan 10, 2022
Report
ABSOLUTELY delicious place!!!!! I had the Cajun bagel with the deviled egg!!!! and the coffee is super good and good flavoring!
The atmosphere from the plants, minimalist and music it’s
Will be back!!!
Isabelle Aengenheyster
Isabelle Aengenheyster
Jan 08, 2022
Report
A delicious café!!! My friends and I went here for lunch and we loved it. I got an everything bagel with plain cream cheese (untoasted) and it was so good! The bagel itself was really salty and flavorful, and the cream cheese was very tasty. My friends got sandwiches and they also loved them. I didn’t interact with the staff much but they seemed really nice. The ambience is also amazing because there are plants everywhere! I was sitting next to a lovely fern but there were plants hanging from the ceiling, climbing up the walls, everywhere!!!! I would definitely recommend this place! (bagels
Emma Valentine
Emma Valentine
Jan 04, 2022
Report
I’ve been here at least a dozen times and my experience is fantastic every time. The team working here are all so friendly and make my day. The food quality is exceptional. I’m convinced the Lox 2.0 on an onion and garlic bagel is one of the best breakfast meals in the city. Would highly recommend the cafe con leche if you’re looking to try a new (and delicious) drink. Stop by if you’re ever in the area!
Colleen Goodhue
Colleen Goodhue
Dec 30, 2021
Report
Swinging through Cambridge and randomly stopped here for a quick bite... And wow. Partner and I both got The Favorite. I got mine with Za'atarn on staff recommendation and it was absolutely divine; crunchy, creamy, herbal, delicious. Coffee was great, location is cute, and the staff's friendly.
A. H.
A. H.
Dec 16, 2021
Report
As a bagel baker myself, these are great bagels. They have good crumb, chew, and crust. Sometimes they toast a bit much for sandwiches, but that’s ok. They have a nice selection most of the time. Make sure to go early.
Tracey-Ann Daley
Tracey-Ann Daley
Sep 03, 2021
Report
3rd time wasn’t a charm. I’m more of a Bagelsaurus/Goldilox girl but now that I’m back in the office I was looking for something in the square. I went for the first time about a week ago and loved it so much I went back the next day! Decided to stop in over the weekend and get my partner a bagel since I had been talking it up and honestly didn’t even look at the time. I’m an early riser and was running errands so just decided to stop on the way home. I walked in(the door was open) at 7:57a-I think they open at 8a and it was clear they were not happy about it. I felt bad and asked “are
Mike Roth
Mike Roth
Aug 20, 2021
Report
I love this place! My favorite sandwich is the avocado toast (on a bagel). There are a couple spots to sit outside but for now it’s mostly take away. The staff are always super nice too.
Ayon Ibrahim
Ayon Ibrahim
Mar 19, 2021
Report
Popular place so it’s pretty busy, especially on a Saturday morning. But the employees are courteous and the food/beverages are tasty. Had a great lox and cream cheese. Also, I got a little sugarcane stick with my latte - cute!