Serving Door County since 1913, the Nightingale Supper Club, Restaurant and Lounge, serves steaks, seafood, poultry, soups and salads. The interior is warm and welcoming with friendly and attentive wait staff, eager to create a memorable dining experience. Nightingale Supper Club features a full menu of delicious appetizers, homemade soups, hearty sandwiches, and gourmet dinner entrees.
Our popular prime rib and fish fry are always a winner. The best in Sturgeon Bay. Come in early to enjoy our bar's happy hour and the great selection of craft beers, wine, and spirits.
Our popular prime rib and fish fry are always a winner. The best in Sturgeon Bay. Come in early to enjoy our bar's happy hour and the great selection of craft beers, wine, and spirits.
Reviews (8)
Debby Zahn
Jan 31, 2022
Report
Jessica
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Firstly I would like to say the customer service was over the top, From the bar to the table every employee made sure we had our drinks , made sure our food was exactly what we ordered ( delicious may i
Add ), absolutely the best experience yet this year at an establishment, we will definitely be back again soon , we definitely recommend you try the mushrooms they are out of this world at first you taste the cream and at the backside the bacon not to mention the prime rib has been the best yet in Door County !!! Hands down best dinner experience yet!!! Thank you , John , Ferra Hailee and Jessica
Add ), absolutely the best experience yet this year at an establishment, we will definitely be back again soon , we definitely recommend you try the mushrooms they are out of this world at first you taste the cream and at the backside the bacon not to mention the prime rib has been the best yet in Door County !!! Hands down best dinner experience yet!!! Thank you , John , Ferra Hailee and Jessica
Angela Potochich
Jan 21, 2022
Report
We went to Nightingale two nights in a row. I'll lost the good and I'll lost the bad.
Good:
The prime rib (this is 5/5 stars and I would recommend coming here for this despite any cons I have)
The cheese curds
The ranch (probably the best I've ever had!)
Bad:
The service. Our servers were fine but the hostess and the bartender the first night could be described as downright rude.
The old fashioneds. The worst brandy old fashioned I've had in my life, very bitter and not the traditional wisco old fashioned I'm used to. I ordered a muddled old fashioned and that was significantly better.
Good:
The prime rib (this is 5/5 stars and I would recommend coming here for this despite any cons I have)
The cheese curds
The ranch (probably the best I've ever had!)
Bad:
The service. Our servers were fine but the hostess and the bartender the first night could be described as downright rude.
The old fashioneds. The worst brandy old fashioned I've had in my life, very bitter and not the traditional wisco old fashioned I'm used to. I ordered a muddled old fashioned and that was significantly better.
Jared S.
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Oscar Prado
Dec 30, 2021
Report
The Nightingale Supper Club is our must-go when in Sturgeon Bay. As a veteran, the wall of honor with pictures of local veterans is very touching. The drinks are well made, the table service is spot-on (thank you Emma!) and the food is FANTASTIC. The prime rib is spectacular and the salmon is delicious. We wish you continued success and many more Happy New Years.
Lori Bankson
Nov 25, 2021
Report
A great local supper club! Reservations requires for the delicious Saturday prime rib-- and it is worth the wait! Drinks and bar staff were both awesome! Waitstaff amazing and friendly. Had an appetizer at the bar and was nice to relax. Brought home cherry pie for dessert-- was delicious. Also reasonably priced!! A true delight in Sturgeon Bay!
Barbara James
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Natalie Seidenkranz
Sep 21, 2021
Report
Slight wait even with reservations. Bar atmosphere was nice though and helped pass the time. Stuffed mushrooms were AMAZING! Definitely would order again. Prime rib had great flavor and was cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the chicken sandwich and was blown away by how good it was. Grasshopper to end the night was great as well. Will definitely be back!
