Cream & Crimson Management
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Founded in 2008, Cream & Crimson Management is a family owned and operated company. Located in Bloomington, Indiana, the corporation owns 100 well-maintained and aesthetically pleasing rental units. This array of properties truly offers something for everyone including houses and condominiums ranging from 1-7 bedrooms.

All of these dwellings are located in close proximity to Indiana University, with none distanced further than one mile from campus. As former athletes and alumni, we understand what it's like looking for a property that will be both convenient and comfortable. We also have commercial property ranging from 600 to 5000 square feet in highly trafficked areas.
Services
Located just across the street from Memorial Stadium this newly renovated, IU themed home is a dream weekend getaway and tailgate space! This 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom rental with a sleeper sofa comfortably sleeps 8. The spacious kitchen comes fully equipped with cookware and dish ware for all of your tailgate needs.
Cream & Crimson Management, LLC is committed to provide our tenants the best experience possible. As property managers, we ensure the complete satisfaction of our clients by offering premium services and well-kept rental homes. Our IU off campus housing units are strategically located in the Bloomington area so students have easy access to shopping malls, parks, and other important amenities.
For all rental related issues and maintenance requests, please use your Appfolio tenant portal to communicate with us. You may also submit a form to us through the "Contact Us" section below. Our cell phone number (text or calls) is not the primary means of communication. Once a request is sent, myself and/or our employees will still handle all issues and questions in the same timely manner.
It often takes an agent 6 - 12 months (possibly more) to sell a house. Before they list, you're expected to make repairs. While it's being shown you're expected to keep the property clean and spotless, so the agent can bring random strangers in to your home at any time, short notice. When you get an offer, you wait for financing to be approved.
Reviews (10)
Cari Gregory
Cari Gregory
Jan 28, 2022
Report
I am moving to the area and Josh was absolutely great at finding me a rental and very responsive. Jenna was just as great. These two made this process so easy and were very professional and helpful. I highly recommend working with Cream and Crimson.
Eric Rosenbaum
Eric Rosenbaum
Aug 30, 2021
Report
Cream & Crimson Management and ALF, LLC are dishonest companies. They have no problem lying to tenants, dishonoring contracts, and threatening legal action to extract as much money as possible.
Cream & Crimson bought my apartment complex from its previous owner in April 2021. Months before the sale, the previous owner had us sign 2021-2022 lease agreements, set to begin in August 2021, which would essentially keep our rent rates in place. Cream & Crimson promised our previous landlord during the transaction that they would honor the new leases, and right after the transaction they told the tenants
Isaac Bentley
Isaac Bentley
Aug 24, 2021
Report
Rented from C&C Properties for over two years and had nothing but a positive experience with them. They have an abundant number of properties available (if you get to them before the students do) and they were always in great condition upon move in. They’re very responsive and their maintenance team (shoutout to Tom especially) always ensures that any major problems are addressed by the next day. Pricing is competitive and very affordable for most locations. The C&C team is extremely flexible and very tenant-oriented. Would definitely rent a property from them again if I were in the area.
Yuelin Wu
Yuelin Wu
Jun 26, 2021
Report
Living address: 725 S Walnut St Bloomington IN 47401
I wanted to give them 5 stars because I liked the apartment and Josh. However, the office isn't helpful towards new tenant and lacking of curtsy.
I was just asking the office to take my apartment key for my subleaser to come to their office and pick the key up, how hard is that? This is a apartment key which matters so much to home security. I'm leaving the U.S next morning at 6am and I don't want to miss handle the key or let it fall in to someone who's not suppose to have it. I thought the office would be the most trustworthy one on keeping
Darren Hurst
Darren Hurst
Aug 26, 2020
Report
This is a company of greedy, crooks. Do not rent from them. Do not use Airbnb from them. They cannot be trusted. Reserved The Porch for graduation weekend and then a week later after confirmation, they decided they wanted 250.00 MORE a night for the rental. I offered to split the difference, as we really wanted it for my sons graduation, but they cancelled the reservation instead. Now we are stuck trying to find a place again. Despicable behavior, and very disappointing.
Lori Denker
Lori Denker
Jul 14, 2020
Report
Cream and Crimson Properties are great! Professional, friendly and responsive. The house I rented was very clean, in great condition and, I really enjoyed my home. I highly recommend this company - you will be happy that you rented from them.
Tricia Petit
Tricia Petit
Jan 29, 2020
Report
I lived in Cream and Crimson’s most recognizable rental for my 2018/19 school year: the red house with the candy striped roof shown on the front page of the website. We knew when we signed the lease in October 2017 that the house wasn’t perfect but we were determined to have a great year. We paid reasonably priced rent because we were females and the landlord said that would we take better care of the house than the frat boys that had been there before.
But let me break it down for you, this house was falling apart. Unfortunately most Bloomington rentals are, this place had...warped floor
Jena Welker
Jena Welker
Jan 20, 2020
Report
I rented from Josh and his company. House was maintained well and the team was very quick on the response whenever we had any issues. Renting again this year and plan to again the following. Highly recommend if you want good quality rentals and a great team to lease from.
Cheney Dale
Cheney Dale
Dec 11, 2019
Report
I had a phenomenal experience while I lived at Cream and Crimson properties for 3 years. All of the homes were extremely well maintained by a group of top notch sub contractors. Josh was easy to deal with and extremely responsive. This is a top tier company that I cannot recommend enough.
Sarah C.
Sarah C.
Oct 18, 2019
Report
We loved renting from Josh and team. They go above and beyond for their tenants. Never had any issues or problems with communication! Definitely have recommended to our family and friends and will continue to do so!