Anna Maria Island Home Rental
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Anna Maria Island Home Rental
AMI Home Rental is a trusted vacation rental business that has been operating since 2011. We've proudly hosted over 7,700 guests in our homes. If you would like to find out more information about why guests can trust us find out more on our Trust Page. Each Waterfront Vacation Rental is handpicked for its waterfront location and proximity to beaches.

Optimizing boating and water recreation while snuggled between two of the most beautiful beaches in the world. Enjoy secluded tropical backyards, echoing sumptuous resort-style luxury. Warm coastal ambiance envelopes you inside each home. For over 10 years we have offered personalized Vacation Planning ideas to thousands of guests.
Services
Instead of us bragging about ourselves, how about we let our guests do the talking for us?. Nancy and Terri were great to deal with and are very concerned with making your vacation stay at Sirenia Beach House the best it can be! The owners provided absolutely outstanding customer service and always responded promptly to emails.
Stay in one of the most spectacular private retreats in Northern Anna Maria Island. Sirenia Beach House is first choice for families, honeymooners, and small groups. Arguably, one of the best tropical backyard retreats on the entire island, reminiscent of a 5-star Caribbean resort. Sirenia Beach House is a five-star waterfront accommodation, blurring the lines between indoor - outdoor living.
Stay in our newest family friendly vacation rental in the city of Anna Maria on Anna Maria Island. Sirenia Cove is a favourite for families with children, honeymooners, and small groups. Showcasing a fresh nautical decor, and cool amenities like the crow's nest replete with working ships wheel, heated pool, hot tub, outdoor TV bar, and backyard kayak launch, it's easy to keep the crew happy without leaving home.
Sirenia By The Sea is located on a quiet residential street, three homes away from the free island trolley and a few steps further to the Gulf of Mexico beach, The shops and restaurants on Gulf Dr are three blocks away and The Sandbar Restaurant is an easy walk. A cheery coastal style interior envelops you, with plush furniture in two living rooms are for you to curl up in.
You won't find any cars on our beaches, it's authentic Old Time Florida Fun. The island beaches stretch seven miles and are pristine! We invite you to do your best to keep them as clean as possible. They are so enticing that the endangered sea turtles and shore birds call Anna Maria Island home and nest here annually.
Reviews (10)
Denise Baur
Denise Baur
Jan 03, 2019
Report
We are excited to be renting from Nancy again in 2019 for the 4th time in the last 5 years. We rented Sirenia Cove the first 2 years and due to our growing extended family we rented Sirenia by the Sea this past November to have more space. We had 6 adults and 6 kids (ages 1-7) and absolutely loved the layout of the house, the awesome pool/backyard and the close proximity to the beach.
Both of the properties are beautifully maintained and Nancy is the best- very responsive and helpful!
Our family has fallen in love with AMI and look forward to it each year!
Kylee Clausen
Kylee Clausen
Dec 29, 2017
Report
We made some great memories at Sirenia Cove this week! It was a perfect fit for our family and had all the amenities we needed (and more!). The pool was great, especially because it was shaded in the afternoon and kept the kids out of the sun. We could also walk to our favorite beaches, shops and ice cream shops. We've stayed in AMI a few times and this was our favorite place!
JohnAndDeb Sherman
JohnAndDeb Sherman
Nov 27, 2017
Report
From day one we had a great feeling about this property. The owners communication from our first contact was exceptional and speedy. Emails containing any and all information that you could think of. Everything is spot on and just like in the pictures. Location is amazing as you can quickly walk to the Gulf or Tampa Bay and walk the beaches. We tried to get out daily and explore a little but honestly the way this place is laid out just made us want to stay put and enjoy a truly relaxing vacation. Privacy is another thing that you might wonder about since places are pretty close on the island but
Mike Dalton
Mike Dalton
Oct 29, 2017
Report
Our second time staying at Sirenia by the Sea, and it was even better than the first. The property itself is in excellent condition, and the owners and management team are very responsive. We had some little issues pop up, and an email to Nancy or Terri and they were taken care of the same day.
The inside was all completely repainted and it looks fabulous! Great color scheme for a tropical paradise. The location is great; 1-1/2 blocks to the ocean, a few minutes by golf cart to both Publix and the Anna Maria General Store.
A new activity we tried this time was kayaking. A canal runs the back
Elizabeth Smith
Elizabeth Smith
Sep 02, 2017
Report
We loved our stay on Anna Maria! Our family of 5 loved the island and the house. The house was supplied with everything you could possibly need during your stay! Seriously, the owners thought of everything! The owners were super nice work with and responded to my questions very quickly. I can not say enough good things about our stay! The kids loved the pool, hot tub, ping pong table and the bunk beds..... oh and having TVs in their rooms!! The boys even went fishing off of the pier, which was a highlight for one of our boys. One morning while looking for sand dollars we saw 3 dolphins playing
Ken Alger
Ken Alger
Nov 05, 2016
Report
Sirenia Cove and Anna Maria Island is a well kept secret. We spent a week there and felt we were in paradise. The house was very spacious and well decorated for convenience and comfort. I loved cooking in the well stocked kitchen - lots of good pots, pans and serving dishes to please anyone. The proximity to the beaches was perfect; walking either way got you to a first rate beach, and if it was too hot to walk the pool in the back yard next to the inland waterway was very inviting! The restaurants nearby offer many options, but I'd highly recommend The Waterfront, IF you not going to stay home
Sarah Elder OrlandoInsiderVacations
Sarah Elder OrlandoInsiderVacations
Sep 29, 2016
Report
The only place we'll stay in Anna Maria Island! Nancy is such a huge help with planning tips and her Insider Guide is packed with awesome info. The homes are immaculately furnished and have everything we need. The outdoor living and pool areas are just dreamy. Can't wait to see you again next year.
Barry White
Barry White
Aug 17, 2016
Report
THE BEST EVER -having travelled for the past 40 years we have now found the house for the ultimate vacation, there was nothing lacking for our needs. our family of 10 plus an infant enjoyed every minute of our holiday. the SIRENIA COVE is walking distance to the beach, restaurants,cafes, ice cream store and famous donut outlet. the grand kids were in the pool from morning till dark and on our final day they took a vote and declared our holiday was THE BEST EVER.we have booked another holiday with two other couples for 2017. A big cheer for Terri and Nancy who provided us with this gem. thanks from
Kim Bergstrom
Kim Bergstrom
Jul 08, 2016
Report
Loved the Anna Maria house (and the owner's other houses that we were able to take a peek inside). Owner was super helpful with suggestions, and it made our vacation that much more special. I'd definitely recommend for getaways to this terrific island. Lots of fun!
J. D. Shenton
J. D. Shenton
Jun 13, 2016
Report
Sirenia Cove
This beautiful home has absolutely everything a family would need for a beach vacation. Every convenience is well thought out and the host is always readily available. We had a few questions/requests during our stay and these were addressed immediately and with pleasure.
The home is gorgeous, with many new and fresh accents to keep it modern (pictures/video accurately reflect the state of the home).
Location is also ideal: short walk to inlet, gulf and shops/restaurants. It is also situated on a cul-de-sac which means very little foot or car traffic. So it is tucked away quietly