Website
Call
The D'Acierno Family has owned and operated John Anthony's since 1985, serving the finest Italian specialties, fresh seafood and meats, along with creative specials, homemade soups, fresh dough pizza and grilled salads! Our menu and weekly seasonal specials boast a variety of options that will appeal to families, as well as the discerning palate looking for that distinct dining experience.

Children can order from a kids' menu while parents can dine on a unique special - all at a reasonable price with healthy portions! Aunt Carol has made the wedding soup, meatballs and sauce since the day we opened our doors! She has hand rolled every homemade meatball with love and her wedding soup is by far the best in western PA.
Reviews (9)
El Lee
El Lee
Dec 28, 2021
Report
We went today for the first time with our daughter. When we walked in, we were seated immediately. Jenn I. was our waitress & brought us menus & drinks, & I asked then for an appitizer, saying we were ready to order. She said, "Sorry, I still have two before you." However, we waited for over 30 minutes & she still hadn't taken our order. She did manage to glance over several times & clean off some tables. There were other waitresses there & they were not that full! Much to the time she was in the back, out of sight.
We left & ended up stopping at King's Family Restaurant. I mention this, because
Ruth Napierkowski
Ruth Napierkowski
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Had Xmas party here, Food was good, room was very nice, private & kid friendly. Great service.
Gjoko Ruzio
Gjoko Ruzio
Nov 24, 2021
Report
We hade take at. Food and service was good. I enjoyed a gin tonic with my Granddad, age 90. Made my day/week.
Tina Dzikiy
Tina Dzikiy
Sep 29, 2021
Report
We only got pizza an beer, which was good, with no complaints. There was one waitress that served five other full tables, an take out, no bartender. She was professional in every way.
Liz K.
Liz K.
Sep 26, 2021
Report
Great food and the best service...at very reasonable prices. Plum doesn't have a ton of restaurants, but even if it did, I would still pick John Anthony's. Had the most delicious lasagna tonight.
Animal Control
Animal Control
Sep 17, 2021
Report
Waitress was great ask for Danelle. Food was plentiful with excellent flavor. Pleasant atmosphere. Would highly recommend.
Christopher Gianfrancesco
Christopher Gianfrancesco
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Celebrating a birthday. Food was very good and reasonably priced. We had a group of around 12 people and the server did an excellent job with the food and drink orders also was very pleasant and efficient. Will definitely return to this venue in the future.
Justin Moore
Justin Moore
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Gina is amazing! She accommodated our last minute pizza order and made us feel welcome even though we arrived close to closing time. Thanks much!!!
David A.
David A.
Feb 03, 2019
Report
John Anthony’s,
I give this location a Five Star,, they have a very large menu,, this restaurant has been here for a long time,, but they seem to take good care of it,, good parking,, restrooms are clean,, the staff is very professional,, the food is great,, we in joyed everything,, they have a full bar,, I recommend this place..