Treat your tastebuds to homestyle Italian-American comfort food at Agatina's. We offer a casual and relaxing atmosphere with freshly made food and great company. As an Italian restaurant located in Rochester, NY, we deliver only the freshest ingredients and most delicious meals. Everything we serve is made to order for you.
From our catering options to our extensive gluten-free menu, we have a meal to satisfy anyone's taste palette. You can indulge in savory seafood or tasty eggplant parmesan and finish your meal off with handmade cannolis at an affordable price. For over 35 years, Agatina's has served Rochester, NY, and surrounding areas with homemade, fresh Italian cuisine.
From our catering options to our extensive gluten-free menu, we have a meal to satisfy anyone's taste palette. You can indulge in savory seafood or tasty eggplant parmesan and finish your meal off with handmade cannolis at an affordable price. For over 35 years, Agatina's has served Rochester, NY, and surrounding areas with homemade, fresh Italian cuisine.
Services
Our Agatina's family is proud to serve yours by bringing freshly cooked food to your next event. If you're having a birthday party, reception, graduation celebration, or more, we are happy to deliver quality Italian catering to you. We serve only the finest meals made with the freshest ingredients, from stuffed mushrooms and bacon-wrapped scallops to entrees by the pan.
At Agatina's, there's something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you need gluten-free options or want to indulge in authentic pasta and succulent seafood dishes, we have it all. For over 30 years, we have been trusted to deliver the most delicious and homemade meals in Rochester, NY. We invite you, your family, and friends to come down to our restaurant and enjoy the casual, welcoming atmosphere and scrumptious food.
As a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant, Agatina's welcomes all to come and try our authentic Italian-American cuisine. It is our goal to ensure everyone is fed right and satisfied with their meal here. We are proud to take reservations and offer the option to purchase gift cards to share our food's deliciousness.
Serving the area of Rochester, NY, for over 30 years, Agatina's invites all to come and experience savory Italian cuisine in a relaxing atmosphere. We have something for everyone, including the kids! Our homestyle Italian eatery is proud to deliver saucy chicken french, eggplant parmesan, and much more.
Reviews (22)
Cathy Sinacola
Jan 01, 2022
Report
Frank Ferrara
Dec 21, 2021
Report
Carol McNees
Dec 18, 2021
Report
Mike Marion
Nov 13, 2021
Report
Ken L.
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Jenna F.
Oct 16, 2021
Report
Jamie Contestabile
Oct 01, 2021
Report
Aryka Bouchard
Sep 30, 2021
Report
Lisa Marie Cimino
Sep 19, 2021
Report
Leucia Maria
Sep 03, 2021
Report
Madelyn P.
Sep 03, 2021
Report
Megan T.
Jul 28, 2021
Report
Update: We have ordered take out multiple times since first review and more than a couple times has my chicken dish not been cooked all the way. I even called the restaurant one time to inform them what was going on, sent a picture, and was told "just put it in the oven at 350 for 10 minutes, the pink will cook out". If I wanted to cook that night, I wouldn't have ordered take out. This has never once happened while dining in so that is what we will stick to for now. We still love the food but we do prefer it cooked all the way.
Scompanyfun D.
Jul 17, 2021
Report
Susan Ross
Jul 07, 2021
Report
Gail Bourdeau Schilling
Apr 25, 2021
Report
Jonathan C.
Jan 19, 2021
Report
Great Italian food! Would love to go back and try more dishes.
Appetizer : steamed clams with butter and lemon juice. Simple and delicious. One order wasn't enough for two people. Had to get two.
Soup: homemade chicken soup was well made.
Entrees : chicken Asiago was juicy. Chicken and vegetables were perfectly soaked in sauce. Two chicken thighs portions were very filling.
Chicken jambalaya with linguini with mild spiciness . Overall wonderful dish. Spiciness was at a perfect mild level. The sauce was oily. Still tasted great.
Noodles : Had Angel hair Noodles in marinara sauce
Appetizer : steamed clams with butter and lemon juice. Simple and delicious. One order wasn't enough for two people. Had to get two.
Soup: homemade chicken soup was well made.
Entrees : chicken Asiago was juicy. Chicken and vegetables were perfectly soaked in sauce. Two chicken thighs portions were very filling.
Chicken jambalaya with linguini with mild spiciness . Overall wonderful dish. Spiciness was at a perfect mild level. The sauce was oily. Still tasted great.
Noodles : Had Angel hair Noodles in marinara sauce
Donald L.
Dec 02, 2020
Report
Rory C.
Aug 27, 2020
Report
Always been a very consistent place. One of my favorite items there is something you will truly never find anywhere else - Seafood Fra Diavalo with a white sauce. It's really misleading because when I think of white sauce, I think Alfredo or a cream sauce... this is a very unique broth-like sauce. I always order it hot!! It's a rare occasion I get back up this way, so it is a must-have when I do. It's a dish I crave often and once I get it, it never disappoints!
UPDATE - if like me, you love Agatina's sauces, you can call and order by the quart!!
UPDATE - if like me, you love Agatina's sauces, you can call and order by the quart!!
Miles L.
Jun 29, 2020
Report
We order here once in awhile since it's really close by. Chicken french is ok, it seems like they don't have consistency with their cooks. Bolognese was different as well from the last time we ordered.
We might try a different restaurant next time we want italian food. Maybe they will get better someday.
We might try a different restaurant next time we want italian food. Maybe they will get better someday.
Michelle D.
Apr 30, 2020
Report
Support local. Ordered take out for dinner. For appetizers ordered Calamari Reggio and broccoli French. Both were delicious. Dinner was chicken and broccoli Alfredo which was plenty enough to share and then have left overs. Curbside delivery was quick and food was hot. Check restaurants Facebook as they run specials everyday.
Michael N.
Jan 31, 2020
Report
First time there, really nice set up. Bars right there when you first walk in. Bartender was really friendly and helpful I asked if they had anything gluten free and she brought me a menu. I was waiting for the rest of my party to get there so I was just looking at the menu.
The rest of my party showed up and we sat in the dining room. Ordered some drinks and then our food. Service was great for the most part. But it took a long time for our main meal to come out. Food was delicious so that made up for it, first restaurant I've been to that had outstanding gluten free dinner rolls and
The rest of my party showed up and we sat in the dining room. Ordered some drinks and then our food. Service was great for the most part. But it took a long time for our main meal to come out. Food was delicious so that made up for it, first restaurant I've been to that had outstanding gluten free dinner rolls and
Kelly Snow
Nov 03, 2018
Report
