We are a modern International tavern featuring International and American sports, local and International beers and an extensive menu including influences from England, Ireland, Scotland and Australia. We love our beer, we have an extensive range of local, national and international brews across 12 taps and 80 bottles and cans.
We rotate often to keep things fresh but of course you'll always find the favorites. The lively bar where you can mingle with the locals? Air conditioned, smoke free, indoor high tables or cozy benches? Outdoors in the Beer Garden against the rail to watch the comings and goings of Duval Street or at a garden table?
We rotate often to keep things fresh but of course you'll always find the favorites. The lively bar where you can mingle with the locals? Air conditioned, smoke free, indoor high tables or cozy benches? Outdoors in the Beer Garden against the rail to watch the comings and goings of Duval Street or at a garden table?
Services
As a well known chef here in Key West for the last 17 years, Chef Andy may have been responsible for your meal at Michael's or Blue Heaven. Andy's love for creating colorful dishes began years ago cooking alongside his mother for himself and his eight siblings. His passion grew over the years as he mastered his skills on the knife under Chef Frank Martinelli of Marstan's Associates Cattering company in La Jolla, California.
Reviews (24)
Lisa Koza
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Ben S.
Jan 24, 2022
Report
Was wandering Duval St and looking for a dinner spot. Settled here because there was no wait and prices were reasonable. My wife wanted some greens so ordered the burrata salad which she absolutely loved. Came with a few big scoops of delicious pesto which worked well. Dinner was the grouper fish and chips for her and the pork belly bahn-mi for me. The fish was good though very thickly battered. Came with potato wedges as it's fries and an interesting smooth tartar sauce. My sandwich was good, though a couple more jalapeños thank I like and a totally different cut of fry than my wife got
Thomas E. C.
Jan 17, 2022
Report
Ron C.
Jan 14, 2022
Report
Decent food and fun atmosphere. This isa great place to go drink with friends. Quite a few locals go for after work drinks and during happy hour, they have deals on their appetizers. I do have to say that the menu options are a mix of seafood choices and American while doing both with mediocrity. This seems to be the norm in Key west but still lots on fun.
Heather K.
Jan 14, 2022
Report
We enjoyed this place for the atmosphere, beer selection and Key Lime Crème Brûlée. However, dinner food was a miss for us. I was excited to get the grouper fish and chips; however, breading was too thick and fish was not the flaky, fresh grouper that I expected. I would highly recommend the Key Lime Crème Brûlée, though!
Michael L.
Jan 10, 2022
Report
My wife and I asked the hotel concierge which way we should walk or do and he said to walk down Duval Street and to go into a place which draws you in. This is exactly what the Old Town Tavern did. It drew us in. We were very impressed with this upscale tavern. They have the NFL package and food and drinks are excellent. Entire staff is very courteous and bartender Michelle is great. Highly recommend this place if you are looking for a reasonable priced restaurant/bar/tavern.
Steven Rightnar
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Santhosh G.
Dec 19, 2021
Report
Nice place to have dinner on historical duval street in Keywest. American restaurant with lot of outdoor and indoor seating with bar and full menu. Not so expensive and good value in quality and quantity. Ordered fish and chips but the chips were so bad. Unseasoned potato wedges were neither crispy nor tasty. Except that, fried fish is tasty. Asparagus tempura is a delicious appetizer with soy ginger sauce. Vegetable banmi is another tasty item if you are vegetarian. Not so crowded on Monday night but the service could be little faster and attentive.
Joe M.
Dec 01, 2021
Report
Traditional tavern with a great outdoor patio right on Duval. They sat us promptly and had timely service. The drinks were great and although we only ordered the french fries they were excellent! They let me sample the sangria before ordering it and checked in on us often. I look forward to coming back here and exploring more of the menu.
Melissa N.
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Brian H.
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Chad T.
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Elba Parra
Nov 01, 2021
Report
Cee Dupree
Oct 15, 2021
Report
Nicky D.
Sep 29, 2021
Report
Rebekah Mitchell
Sep 14, 2021
Report
Claire A.
Aug 13, 2021
Report
Not much to say. It was air conditioned on a hot day and the service was great but the food was meh. 3 of us ate, none cared for our lunch. I had fish and chips, outside was burned, inside tasteless. My sister had something that repeated on her all day as did my son. The key lime brulee was good they said
Jennifer O.
Aug 08, 2021
Report
On our recent trip, we ventured into this establishment a few times. Happy hour 4-7pm and 11pm-1am, score! They also had 50% off whiskey and bourbon after 9pm. And lastly half off appetizers and flatbreads. The first night we stopped in, I had a Smoky Bloody Mary. I would rate the bloody Mary's by itself as 5 stars!! Dinner the 2nd night we ordered a buffet (jokingly): Gazpacho, Scotch Eggs and a wedge salad. Dinner: Shepard's Pie for me and a steak sandwich for husband. We rolled out of there happy and sleepy. Lol. On our last night, I ordered the Shrimp Linguine and the hubby got the
Jason F.
Jul 28, 2021
Report
I stopped by here a couple of Wednesdays ago as part of a party of 6 for lunch. We happened to be walking down Duval St whenever we noticed the menu of Old Town Tavern and Beer Garden and thought that it looked interesting enough to try. My wife and her parents got seated while I went to grab my parents and show them where we were eating lunch. Old Town Tavern and Beer Garden has both indoor and outdoor seating as you might guess from the name. Since we were at the back of the inside seating I can't speak to the outside. The inside here had a giant bar along one wall and then tons of
Brian F.
Jul 10, 2021
Report
Robert Corman
Jun 12, 2021
Report
Rachel Iverson
Apr 15, 2021
Report
Ordered the 2 hangover burgers and salad. We sat ourselves outside, waited 10 minutes for a server, another 10 for water. The food took 45 minutes. One burger was cooked to perfection, but the other was burnt and dry. Server didn’t have time to check on the cook so we couldn’t get that one switched. Took another 15-20 for the check. The server apologized and was very kind, but obviously too busy to get to us.
Keity B.
Oct 30, 2020
Report
We came in during the Covid days where things close down fairly early and so we had to grab a bite to eat. The choices were slim due to the recent closing times.
Pros: The old town burger was good and the fries were tasty and fresh. The grouper burger was good too.
Cons: We had the black bean hummus and it tasted fermented, and after some thought, it looked like they had jared them up into small jars and they cut up a few random items onto a plate- sliced bell peppers, some cauliflower, boxed bread biscuits and the black bean dip. I wouldn't order this again. Also, the table sticky
Pros: The old town burger was good and the fries were tasty and fresh. The grouper burger was good too.
Cons: We had the black bean hummus and it tasted fermented, and after some thought, it looked like they had jared them up into small jars and they cut up a few random items onto a plate- sliced bell peppers, some cauliflower, boxed bread biscuits and the black bean dip. I wouldn't order this again. Also, the table sticky
Erica S.
Sep 18, 2020
Report
Stopped in here after the tour at the Hemingway house. We were sat by a hostess and noticed they were enforcing social distancing.
Our server was finishing up with another table so our hostess took our drink order and brought us water.
Our cocktails were awesome! I had a key lime martini (can't remember the exact name) and wow! I'd love the recipe! Super yummy! Hubby had the rum runner which was super strong and tasty!
We decided to order a few appetizers. We ordered meatballs, fried mozzarella and conch fritters.
The meatballs were ok but not the greatest. The others were great
Our server was finishing up with another table so our hostess took our drink order and brought us water.
Our cocktails were awesome! I had a key lime martini (can't remember the exact name) and wow! I'd love the recipe! Super yummy! Hubby had the rum runner which was super strong and tasty!
We decided to order a few appetizers. We ordered meatballs, fried mozzarella and conch fritters.
The meatballs were ok but not the greatest. The others were great
