Overflowing dishes of the best Italian cuisine that Boca Grande, FL has to offer is only found at Sisters Restaurant! Located at the corner of 5th Street and East Railroad Avenue under the big Banyan tree, Sisters Restaurant offers the most mouth-watering Italian and affordable cuisine, made daily from only the freshest of premium ingredients, passionately created by their Chef, Monty Caputo.
Chef Monty is no stranger to knowing what it takes in creating only the best for his clients; he has been an Italian Chef for over 30 years and even went to Culinary School in Napoli, Italy. He's just a little Italian! Customers leave more than satisfied, they go home WOWED!
Chef Monty is no stranger to knowing what it takes in creating only the best for his clients; he has been an Italian Chef for over 30 years and even went to Culinary School in Napoli, Italy. He's just a little Italian! Customers leave more than satisfied, they go home WOWED!
Reviews (24)
Nancy O.
Jan 08, 2022
Report
Maria R.
Jan 03, 2022
Report
We went for lunch as a party of 9. The grouper fingers were the star of show, perfectly battered, the fish was fresh and the portions were generous. There was less satisfaction with the ultimate fish sandwich, which had the same fish but a lot less of it for the same price. Others ordered burgers and pizzas, which were pronounced OK. The only disappointment was the Caesar salad, which had mass produced dressing and croutons and was quite expensive for the portion. Service was friendly and attentive.
David Parker
Dec 30, 2021
Report
Terrible customer service. Called ahead two hours before closing on multiple attempts. The phone just rang with no answer. Walked over to order carry out or dine in. I was told no more service and as pointed out previously I had called two hours before closing. At that time the counter lady pointed at the phone and showed me that she had unplugged the phone. If I was your owner I would be taking a real close look at my staff. My order potentially would have been a large cheese pizza and jalapeño poppers. Seems this could be done in two hours but not by people that don’t want to work. Guaranteed
Jp Allen
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Sara G. G.
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Heidi F.
Jul 03, 2021
Report
Jonathan Fudge
Jun 21, 2021
Report
Stopped imnto get a drink and stayed for a pizza. It looked so good and the staff were so nice that we decided to stay and eat.
A really amazing experience here was running into one of their staff who was hearing impared. She was super nice and was happy to let me practice what little sign language I knew.
The people in the restaurant seemed liked they were locals and regulars and everyone seemed super nice. Very happy with the experience overall.
Oh, and the pizza 🍕 was very tasty!
A really amazing experience here was running into one of their staff who was hearing impared. She was super nice and was happy to let me practice what little sign language I knew.
The people in the restaurant seemed liked they were locals and regulars and everyone seemed super nice. Very happy with the experience overall.
Oh, and the pizza 🍕 was very tasty!
O. Fernandes
Jun 17, 2021
Report
I guess being one of the few restaurants open in the evening they feel they have a right to treat people rudely.
1st off they do not answer their phone. I attempted to call for an hour for a carry out . I finally ended up driving to the restaurant. Upon entry, I was totally ignored for at least 15 minutes until I asked if someone could take my order. My pizza finally arrived and I went home. I figured I paid 25.00 for one of the worst pizzas to cross my palette plus a tip to be treated rudely. They stay in business because there is basically nowhere else to go for a simple meal,, and most weekenders
1st off they do not answer their phone. I attempted to call for an hour for a carry out . I finally ended up driving to the restaurant. Upon entry, I was totally ignored for at least 15 minutes until I asked if someone could take my order. My pizza finally arrived and I went home. I figured I paid 25.00 for one of the worst pizzas to cross my palette plus a tip to be treated rudely. They stay in business because there is basically nowhere else to go for a simple meal,, and most weekenders
Chrissy M.
Jun 15, 2021
Report
The Aquatic Keeper
Jun 11, 2021
Report
Heather Corinne
May 30, 2021
Report
Our family reunion (about 43 of us) was held at Gasparilla Inn this past Memorial Day weekend. Thursday on arrival day a large group of us were hungry and despite them closing at 9pm, (18) of us were accommodated at 8:45pm. Savanah was our server and was awesome! Great service and great food! Thank you!
Terry G.
Mar 25, 2021
Report
Nyla DeMar
Mar 17, 2021
Report
The food is average-mediocre. We ordered shrimp with Buffalo sauce on the side and when the meal came out were told ‘the cook didn’t want to do that’. The shrimp was soggy. Very rude attitude. Also ordered the margarita pizza with no tomato add sauce. They charged to remove the tomato. Who charges to remove a ingredient? 🤦🏼♀️ Will not be back.
Lauren T.
Feb 21, 2021
Report
Came to Boca as a get a way. Stopped for drinks at other places nearby and wasn't thrilled. Stumbled across this and had a phenomenal waitress named Savannah. Food was plentiful and excellent. Definitely a must visit. Would have posted pictures but food was so goo we ate it before I could get a chance.
Corey E.
Feb 14, 2021
Report
Ellen G.
Sep 19, 2020
Report
Sisters is a GEM!!! I Grew up in Italy more specifically Naples so when it comes to pasta I tend to be a snob. But when I took a bite into that seafood marinara I drifted back to my childhood, eating at our local restaurant by the beach. It was ahhmmaazzinnnggg!!! The pasta was perfectly cooked and the sauce was on point!! I was visiting from virginia on memorial day weekend ans my sister and brother in law took us to Boca Grande. I loved this place so much I took my parents down (FROM Virginia) just to see this beautiful place and to eat at sisters. Not being a floridian, I was not aware of off
Jodi K.
Mar 21, 2020
Report
We called on a Tuesday night (3/10/2020) and were put on hold. We assumed the restaurant was busy so remained on hold. My friend and I tagged teamed and in the mean time, our husbands drove to Sisters to order our pizza. We were on hold 36 minutes! We listened to them taking orders from other customers and then from our husbands. No apology for keeping us on hold except for they forgot about us. Pizza was good but the customer service and attitude of the employees is awful!
Victoria P.
Feb 08, 2020
Report
Three of us went in for dinner and two of our orders were wrong. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, a large pepperoni pizza without sauce, and a small pepperoni with onion pizza. The waitress refused to tell us what was in the dipping sauce for the appetizer bread. It took over an hour for the food to be delivered to the table. Every other table had been served, and we were still waiting for our food.
The waitress brought the small pepperoni with onion pizza first, and it took another 10 minutes for the large pizzas to be brought out. The small pepperoni with onion pizza was very under baked
The waitress brought the small pepperoni with onion pizza first, and it took another 10 minutes for the large pizzas to be brought out. The small pepperoni with onion pizza was very under baked
Lyle D.
Feb 06, 2020
Report
Vince S.
Jun 17, 2019
Report
We enjoyed Sisters Restaurant last night. Party of six, we made a reservation and when we arrived were seated immediately. Wine list was great, service was about what we expected, the restaurant was hopping, lots of people waiting to get seated when we walked up. We had chicken piccatta, an antipasto salad, a pizza, and chicken parmesan. It was all pretty awesome, the only potential improvement would be a little more broiler action to char the cheese on the chicken dishes.
We also hammered some appetizers, two thumbs up for the cheese sticks and the jalapeno poppers. The bread was also
We also hammered some appetizers, two thumbs up for the cheese sticks and the jalapeno poppers. The bread was also
Andrew M.
Mar 17, 2019
Report
Sisters was very good. Their menu looked great, but we only were able to try some salads and pizza. Staff was friendly and service was fair for how busy they were. They take alot of reservations so busy times of year you may want make one if you have a large party or want to sit outside.
The side salads were a Good size and the pizza was tastey. Better then average. I would go back again and eat there for sure.
The side salads were a Good size and the pizza was tastey. Better then average. I would go back again and eat there for sure.
Laura Jones
Jun 19, 2018
Report
Jennifer Velasquez
Sep 10, 2017
Report
Shelley R.
Mar 08, 2017
Report
Nice place to go after a day on the beach or when visiting Boca Grande.
we had appetizers and drinks here and enjoyed them a lot! Our waitress was energetic and fun, and was patient explaining all the different types of beer they have, and they have a good variety. It was a great way to end a beautiful day here on Boca Grande!!
we had appetizers and drinks here and enjoyed them a lot! Our waitress was energetic and fun, and was patient explaining all the different types of beer they have, and they have a good variety. It was a great way to end a beautiful day here on Boca Grande!!
