Reynolds Realty
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Reynolds Realty
At Reynolds Realty, our focus is on exceptional management of homes, condos, and townhomes in the area. If you own a residential investment home and are looking for professional management, look no further! We provide full management services, including marketing, tenant screening, leasing, maintenance, and accounting.

Our reputation is the best in the area - just ask our current clients. If you are looking to rent a home, we have a top-notch inventory of houses, condos, and townhomes for lease. You can view our ability in real-time, find the perfect next home for you, and apply to rent with us. When you rent from us, you can be assured of a high-level of professionalism and quick maintenance response.
Services
Buying, Selling, Leasing, or need a Property Management company, we can assist you in any of your real estate needs. Reynolds Realty has been in existence well over 34 years. Jill has been in Real Estate a number of years with most of those being in Property Management, plus our competent real estate team in the Tulsa Metro Area, can help you whether new to this area or just moving around.
At Reynolds Realty, Inc. we are committed to protecting the privacy of our customers' personal information. You have chosen to do business with us, and we think your trust in us is fundamental to our continuing business relationship. We recognize our obligation to keep the information you provide to us secure and confidential.
Thank you for expressing interest in Reynolds Realty Management Company. By reading our management packet, you will see why so many other investors have decided to entrust the management of their investment properties to the professionals at Reynolds Realty, Inc. Never has the need for a professional real estate manager been as acute as it is today.
Reviews (11)
Olivia Lyons
Olivia Lyons
Apr 29, 2021
Report
I was running late, due to a work meeting, to a rental property viewing and tried to contact the property manager via phone call to inform them that I was running behind, with no response. I then text a number that I got off a voicemail, got an immediate response so my phone call was obviously ignored. I was then told that she already left, I didn't receive any curtesy call, text or email to say that they were leaving so I would have shown up to no one there to show the home.
Then to top it all off I was informed that they already have an approved application and were going to tell me when I arrived
Leslie Wright
Leslie Wright
Oct 03, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Jill and Shira are both wonderful to work with! They are both very responsive to phone calls and if any repairs arise they get someone to contact you the next day if not sooner. I would definitely recommend renting from them.
Maria M. Villegas
Maria M. Villegas
Jul 09, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
We only have had positive things to say about Reynolds service we worked with them for 7 years. Every year their professional staff was always up for the challenges and worked very well with the tenants and with us as homeowners trusting them with our house .
Sandra Cone
Sandra Cone
Jun 23, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism
Jill and Shira are very professional. My calls are answered or returned promptly. Any maintenance issues are taken care of within 48 hours or sooner. I've had a great experience with them and am so happy with the rental house. I would recommend Reynolds Realty.
Ricardo Villegas
Ricardo Villegas
Jun 06, 2020
Report
Jill, is a true professional. In the many years of house rental. Jill not only did her job, but eliminate stress from me, in order for me to complete my normal day to day events.
Jill found qualified renters, paid on time, conducted inspection, handled our home repairs with great results and even from time to time provided good counsel.
Jill and her office is a company I will recommend. They handle business like it should. They speck to you as business partners. It’s a business of excellence executive morales and ethic.
Angela S.
Angela S.
Apr 03, 2020
Report
Our house was a part of the flood in May 2019. They were quick and accommodating to get the house we wanted to rent ready for us as quickly as possible due to our need for housing ASAP. With any issues we have had they are quick to get a repair man out without hesitation. Highly recommend!!!
Donnarae Phillips
Donnarae Phillips
Oct 10, 2019
Report
There were some very frustrating instances working with one particular person at this company, but when Jill had to get involved because of an unreasonable land lord it was apparent that she cared and was working hard to make it right. As a tenant, I would rent from them again. However, I would try to only work with Jill. When we had an issue, they were quick to respond and get someone to fix it.
Jon Phillips
Jon Phillips
Sep 26, 2018
Report
I'm updating this review as it became apparent that many of the issues we were facing with our house were largely a result of the owner not being cooperative with Reynolds or with me. Jill did all in her power to help get major issues resolved even when the owner was refusing to comply.
Jill was always very responsive to our calls and emails and continued to be so even after the property switched management companies.
Liz Reynolds
Liz Reynolds
Nov 12, 2016
Report
I rented a home managed by Reynolds Realty for two years and while Jill was always kind and communicative, our experience was sub par at best. Jill's kind personality is the only reason I am giving RR more than one star.
Our issues included being charged for maintainance that never happened, being charged unfairly for cleaning after we moved out and had the house professionally cleaned, and being charged for holes in the yard that we neither created and also filled in as a measure of good faith. Jill assured my boyfriend we would not be charged for cleaning during our exit interview, yet we were
Vincent Chung
Vincent Chung
Jun 09, 2015
Report
By far my worst experience with property management, and I have rented in over 10 different locations. Dealing with the Reynolds' staff is a struggle. I rarely can get a hold of them over the phone. My work is an hour away, it is impossible to schedule a sit-down appointment with them because of their short business hours (Mon-Fri, 9AM - 3PM). The staff is rude and condescending.
Reynolds would find any excuse to charge me for services that aren't expected or outlined clearly in the lease agreement. I was charged with a maintenance bill because no one was home to let the repairman in. I was not
Marie Perret
Marie Perret
Nov 30, 2014
Report
Extremely disappointed with the service. We stayed at a Reynolds property for several years. We paid in full and on time, took care of the property, and followed the policies and procedures outlined in our lease.
It was almost impossible to get in touch with the office staff since business hours were 10-3, Monday-Friday. The office ladies take very long lunch breaks and do not return messages. There were 2 instances where we had an emergency maintenance issue but did not get an answer from Reynolds despite leaving messages with the answering service and calling the emergency maintenance phone