Since 1927, Reuter's has been providing families with the most delectable pastries, breads and baked goods that have ever graced their tabletops. Generation after generation have whispered the sweet secret of Reuter's offerings throughout the years, making this bakery the passion of both fond, storied memories as well as the sugar-stuffed dreams of our growing youth.
Please take time to peruse the delicious visuals of our website as if you were strolling right through our warm bakery itself. If you're not lucky enough to walk into our doors today, our website will surely make you wish that you were. Thank you so much for choosing Reuter's Bakery.
Please take time to peruse the delicious visuals of our website as if you were strolling right through our warm bakery itself. If you're not lucky enough to walk into our doors today, our website will surely make you wish that you were. Thank you so much for choosing Reuter's Bakery.
Services
Step inside our gallery of charming and engaging cakes and your mind will wander searching for the stories behind their creation. Our mastery of the visual art of cake making is matched only by the fine ingredients and wonderful tastes that we bake into them. Cakes can be the centerpiece of any culinary presentation and Reuter's cakes blossom with eye-catching bursts of color and design.
Your most important day is truly our most important focus. Reuter's Bakery specializes in creating a wedding cake that is as elegant and as memorable as the wedding event itself. The cake is crafted from the finest and most precious of ingredients mixed together with careful precision until we are ready to add the crucial, final ingredient; our creativity.
Fortunate is the person who walks by a bakery just as the newest batch of breads are removed from the hot oven, the aroma wrapping around the senses like a quilt of fond memories. Come inside to relive that sensation again and again. Some would say our baked breads could not get any better. That's when we add a little sugar and sweets to the mix to take it up one more level just to prove them wrong.
Reviews (10)
Steph C.
Dec 30, 2021
Report
They put care into every crafted item they bake. This place was my first job in high school 17 years ago, I still go back to get cakes and pastries. That tells you a lot about a place. They use high quality ingredients and also make fun seasonal pastries. My favorite items are the raspberry torte cake, cherry kolaczki, hand made turtle candies and fresh strawberries custom cakes. I have more favorites but go see and try for yourself.
Syl Zal
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Gianna Ortiz
Nov 24, 2021
Report
Rachy Vazquez
Nov 16, 2021
Report
Donna Lawny
Sep 09, 2021
Report
Very upsetting..got my daughter’s birthday cake here and they totally messed it up!! Asked for Chocolate Buttercream and they put regular Buttercream on it. Don’t these people check their cakes? When I went to pick it up, all the lady at the counter said was”the baker must have read it wrong”. Seriously??? I get $10.00 off for the birthday cake my daughter wouldn’t eat…God forbid it wasn’t a wedding cake…
Lamar Grant
Aug 30, 2021
Report
Marc
Aug 24, 2021
Report
Been going to this place since I was a teenager in 1970. So incredible! Working at the family butcher shop 1 block East as a youngster, I'd make a regular stop here during coffee breaks, as well as every single Saturday after breakfast to pick up 2 dozen Variety for the entire crew. This bakery is Legend! Old world attention, like going back in time! Love their eclairs, coffee cakes, cookies and their doughnuts. Whenever I visit home, I always stop by Reuter's when I'm nearby. You just HAVE to!
Lena Rodriguez
Jul 03, 2021
Report
I cannot say enough good things about the quality of the cake and cupcakes we ordered. The customer service was exceptional and the price was extremely reasonable, I was surprised with how low the bill was. The cake was BEAUTIFUL and so freaking delicious! We ordered 2 dozen cupcakes - mix of vanilla and chocolate filled with whip cream... perfection! I won't be going to any other bakery again.
Joneneisha Jones
Nov 23, 2020
Report
Ania Iwanski
Nov 22, 2018
Report
Our wedding was in November, and our venue uses Reuter's Bakery for cakes. Let me just say, our cake was AMAZING! Nancy was so kind and easy to work with. She gave us many samples to taste, all of which were super moist & flavorful. I showed her a picture of what I wanted the cake to look like, and they nailed it! Highly recommend - I had lots of guests ask where our cake was from. Thank you Reuter's for a deliciously perfect cake!
