Paragon Place At Bishops Bay
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Paragon Place Apartments represents the very best that the Middleton, Wisconsin, area luxury apartment living has to offer. Our pet friendly community is located in the highly desirable Watermark neighborhood in the Community of Bishops Bay and represents a desirable combination of modern amenities, sophisticated style and remarkable value, featured in one and two bedroom apartment styles.

Whether you're catching an early morning or after hours workout in our state-of-the-art 24 hour Fitness Center, meeting a friend for coffee and enjoying all the modern conveniences of our Paragon Perk Internet Cafe', or catching the game and shooting billiards with friends in The Clubhouse, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay is designed with your active, healthy and social lifestyle in mind.
Services
Effortless living has never been easier. From the moment you step inside Paragon Place at the Community of Bishops Bay, you'll know you've found your new apartment. With attention to detail around every corner, everything in our pet friendly community has been designed with you in mind.

Focused on the active, healthy and social lifestyle of its residents, Paragon Place at the Community of Bishops Bay, provides amenities second-to-none, including The Clubhouse, 24-hour Fitness Center, the Paragon Perk Internet Cafe and Coffee Bar, heated underground parking and so much more!Combine all this with an ideal location in Middleton, and it's clear why Paragon Place at the Community at Bishops Bay is such a highly desirable community.
And for our dog lovers, just minutes from Paragon Place, the community of Middleton offers a year round off-leash dog park and dog exercise area open daily from 8am - 10pm. The park is equipped with shade shelter, picnic tables, drinking water, a fenced agility course, portable restrooms, dog waste disposal bags, and mowed trails.
Experience the exceptional attention to detail and design that only Paragon Place at the Community at Bishops Bay in Middleton, Wisconsin can deliver. Our collection of spacious, open-concept one and two bedroom floor plans range in size from 775-1386 square feet.

Enjoy exclusive golf course and park views, open-concept kitchens featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, plank floors, Kohler gooseneck faucets and top-of-the-line finishes.Abundant walk-in closets, private washer and dryer, oversized bedrooms and living rooms, near floor-to-ceiling windows, expansive patios/balconies and more!
Reviews (9)
Nancy Youngquist
Nancy Youngquist
Dec 19, 2021
Report
I absolutely love living at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay. I haven't lived in an apartment since my 20's and decided a year and a half ago that I didn't want to be a homeowner anymore. I don't care if I ever move again. I have a beautiful apartment in a great location with an excellent management and maintenance team. The building seems to be very well constructed -- very quiet and secure. I can't imagine a better place to live!
Julie Worman
Julie Worman
Jul 28, 2021
Report
This is a wonderful place to live! I’ve been here since November 2020. I moved from Reno,NV and the transition was excellent, seamless. Office management was responsive, attentive to every last detail. Service and maintenance is excellent as well- timely response. The location is great, the grounds and community- beautiful. thank you so much Paragon Place at the Community of Bishops Bay!
Colleen Francis
Colleen Francis
Jul 21, 2021
Report
My partner and I, along with our little dog, have been living at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay for over two years now. We love how friendly and kind our neighbors are, and of course how helpful, kind, and amazing the management staff is! We've only ever had a handful of maintenance-worthy issues and they have always been resolved as soon as possible and with great communication. We absolutely love living here and would highly recommend it to anyone!
Kathy Faith-Barnett
Kathy Faith-Barnett
Jun 27, 2021
Report
I love my apartment at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay. I've lived her 2+ years. The management and maintenance staff are great and respond immediately to issues. The underground parking is great for the winter months. I looked at a lot of apartments before I found this one and it is definitely high quality. I would recommend Paragon Place at Bishops Bay if you are looking.
Yue Leng
Yue Leng
Jun 17, 2021
Report
It is so nice to live here. The management team is very sweet and responsible. The maintenance technician is very nice and professional. They always take care of your concern quickly and solve the problem as soon as possible. They make life sweet and cozy here.
Donald Schultz
Donald Schultz
May 05, 2021
Report
April 20, 2021
My wife and I have been living at Paragon Place apartments for the last four years on the first floor of 5216 Bishops Bay Parkway.
We both would give this apartment complex high marks for several reasons. First, we love the location as it is a rural setting with a beautiful park adjunct to the building. We are about three minutes to University Ave and 10 minutes to the village of Waunakee. There are grocery stores close by, a pharmacy, hardware store, post office, and gas station in Waunakee and Middleton. The complex is dog-friendly with reasonable restrictions.
We feel very
Janice Bryant
Janice Bryant
Apr 18, 2021
Report
I have been a part of Paragon Place Communtiy of Bishops Bay since August of 2017. This is my first rental experience since I was in my 20's, my plan was to live in an apartment for 1 year and decide where I wanted to buy my next home. This is my home, I Love it here! I can come and go and have no responsibility of a homeowner. The grounds, the staff, the amenities have always met my expectations! I believe I have high expectations in life, so for this I am Happy!
Suzie DeB
Suzie DeB
Mar 27, 2021
Report
It's hard to imagine better apartment living than Paragon Place at Bishops Bay. We moved in when phase 3 was completed in 2017 and have enjoyed every minute. The building is well constructed and maintained, the staff is responsive and friendly and the amenities are more than adequate. Whenever I see our manager showing prospective tenants around, I comment what a wonderful place this is. One last thing- the views of the adjacent park and distant Conservancy are outstanding.
Megan
Megan
May 19, 2020
Report
We lived here for 2 years before purchasing a home, and can confidently say this was the best rental experience we had in the Madison-area (and we lived in various apartments/rentals over a combined 16 years!!). Management was always quick to respond to queries/requests, the buildings were well-maintained and cleaned frequently, and the amenities were above average (clean pool, good gym equipment, clean/bright parking facilities). If you're looking for a home, check this place out - and say "Hello" to Kullen for us :)