Intrigue Indy
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Intrigue Indy
Intrigue Indy is a high-service property management and leasing company based in Indianapolis, Indiana. We take pride in the fact that each of our properties are unique & personally managed. We have all the right tools to help you efficiently list, market, show, and lease your property at a fair market rate to a screened and qualified prospective tenant.

Whether you're looking to buy a diamond in the rough or sell a property to realize your ROI, we are your one-stop shop for all things Indiana real estate. In the age of automation and robocalls, we believe a personal phone call or text is best to get the job done, service our properties, and stay in communication.
Services
Since 2018, the Intrigue Property Management team has been serving our clients through industry-leading leasing practices, top property management expertise, and real estate services. Intrigue Property Management is a high-service property management and leasing company based in Indianapolis, Indiana.
While all listed services can be used la carte and are available on an as needed basis, we have designed our services to provide our clients with a complete, end-to-end solution. Intrigue clients who use more than one of our services experience increased seamlessness, fewer handoffs, and less headaches.
We offer property leasing services that meet and exceed market expectations, achieving swift property occupancy and top market rent rates. We capture high quality listing photos and feature your property on over 60+ reputable sites, including multiple social media platforms & intrigueindy.com. Properties are leased to qualified tenants who undergo a thorough, industry-leading screening process and receive final approval from the owner.
We offer renovation management solutions for projects large and small, overseeing the entire project from the scope of work to project completion. We consult with you to complete a "scope of work" for the property design & finishes, leaning on our leasing and property expertise. We obtain below-market estimates for the project from a network of dedicated contractors.
Whether you are looking to find and purchase or sell a property, we are here to be your dedicated team of licensed real estate agents. Are you an investor looking to add a property to your portfolio? First-time homebuyer? No matter your level of experience or budget, we can help you find the home that matches the exact criteria you are looking for.
Reviews (11)
Sierra Aylsworth
Sierra Aylsworth
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Unfortunately, we didn't rent from these guys, but up to the point of signing the lease they were awesome! Great communication and response time. Out of all the companies I have dealt with these guys have blown them out of the water with getting you taken care of quickly!
Thank you!
Genna Hall
Genna Hall
Oct 29, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
My husband and I have been with intrigue Indy for 2 years. They are a great company to use, we look forward to signing our next lease with them.
Andrew Winneroski
Andrew Winneroski
Oct 28, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
The Intrigue team are incredibly professional, timely, and do nothing but quality work! I can personally assure you that you cannot go wrong choosing Intrigue. Will definitely be using Intrigue for any and all future property endeavors! If you aren’t sure who to pick - pick Intrigue!
Stephen O'Maley
Stephen O'Maley
Oct 26, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Working with Intrigue has been an incredible experience. They are very personable and will do whatever it takes to get the job done.
Nate Hall
Nate Hall
Oct 21, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I have been renting with intrigue Indy for about 2 years Now. they are responsive, have good prices and always work with you. Looking forward to re signing.
Mary Bradley
Mary Bradley
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Positive: Responsiveness
The property just had a lot of kinks that needed/ still need to be worked out. Other than that things go smoothly. It was rocky in the beginning but they responded when needed. Paying rent is easy and their staff is professional.
Justin Underwood
Justin Underwood
Apr 27, 2021
Report
I've been renting with Intrigue Indy for 2 months. I highly recommend checking their listings out first before going anywhere else. Daniel and his team are highly responsive to my needs and I've had no issues in dealing with them. They were very up front and honest with me before I signed the lease and continue to check in to make sure I'm living comfortably.
Before moving to the Reagan Park area on the northside of downtown with Intrigue, I was having issues dealing with countless property agencies who would not respond to emails. Getting tours and meeting with actual people to discuss the lease
David Brinkworth
David Brinkworth
Dec 31, 2020
Report
We have dealt with Intrigue Indy for the last 2 years. They are a great group of very hard work people. They currently do all our leasing and property management and I'm very pleased with the overall service they provide. Ryan, Daniel and Emilee are a great team and provide all the services we need on a daily basis. If you are looking for a Property Management team you should definitely use Intrigue.
Sallen
Sallen
Sep 29, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Intrigue Indy Property Management have been amazing! They work hard and take care of my property and the tenants. They respond to your needs quickly and really work hard to make your experience smooth. I definitely recommend this company to take care of your property.
Topher K.
Topher K.
Jul 24, 2020
Report
Recently my family and I sold our home. The home we're buying is not ready yet. We found a short term rental through Airbnb with Intrigue Indy. Looked great, excited for a month of downtown living for my family and I. The home was listed as fully furnished and pet friendly. I reached out to verify pets were good and that a family of 6 (4 young kids) would be a good fit before requesting the 30 day rental.

Upon arrival there were a ton of small issues; forced late check in due to their previous tenants, no cleaning supplies, 3 spoons, 5 forks, little stuff that I did my best to work with
Mathew H.
Mathew H.
Mar 04, 2020
Report
Ryan and his team are excellent! I'm an out of state investor and they're made these investments as smooth and passive as possible. They've always gone above and beyond in terms of managing the properties and helping me understand the Indianapolis market to help me reach my goals. Ryan has walked numerous properties for me and provided me videos and his detailed analysis on potential deals. Ryan and Daniel have helped me navigate challenging tenant situations. They've been super responsive with repair/maintenance calls, rent payment issues and overall very smooth to work with